Ramsey Lauren, O'Hara Jane, Lawton Rebecca, Sheard Laura
Yorkshire Quality and Safety Research Group, Bradford Royal Infirmary, Bradford, UK.
School of Healthcare, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Sociol Health Illn. 2023 Mar;45(3):642-665. doi: 10.1111/1467-9566.13607. Epub 2023 Jan 17.
Healthcare staff are encouraged to use feedback from their patients to inform service and quality improvement. Receiving patient feedback via online channels is a relatively new phenomenon that has rarely been conceptualised. Further, the implications of a wide, varied and unknown(able) audience being able to view and interact with online patient feedback are yet to be understood. We applied a theoretical lens of dramaturgy to a large ethnographic dataset, collected across three NHS Trusts during 2019/2020. We found that organisations demonstrated varying levels of 'preparedness to perform' online, from invisibility through to engaging in public conversation with patients within a wider mission for transparency. Restrictive 'cast lists' of staff able to respond to patients was the hallmark of one organisation, whereas another devolved responding responsibility amongst a wide array of multidisciplinary staff. The visibility of patient-staff interactions had the potential to be culturally disruptive, dichotomously invoking either apprehensions of reputational threat or providing windows of opportunity. We surmise that a transparent and conversational feedback response frontstage aligns with the ability to better prioritise backstage improvement. Legitimising the autonomous frontstage activity of diverse staff groups may help shift organisational culture, and gradually ripple outwards a shared responsibility for transparent improvement.
鼓励医护人员利用患者反馈来改进服务和提升质量。通过在线渠道接收患者反馈是一种相对较新的现象,很少有人对其进行概念化。此外,广大、多样且未知(或可确定)的受众能够查看在线患者反馈并与之互动,其影响尚待了解。我们将拟剧理论视角应用于2019/2020年期间在三个国民保健服务信托基金收集的大量人种志数据集。我们发现,各组织在网上展示出不同程度的“表演准备”,从隐身到在更广泛的透明度使命下与患者进行公开对话。能够回应患者的员工“演员名单”受限是一个组织的标志,而另一个组织则将回应责任下放给众多多学科员工。患者与员工互动的可见性有可能在文化上造成干扰,引发对声誉威胁的担忧或提供机会之窗。我们推测,透明且对话式的反馈回应前台与更好地确定后台改进优先级的能力相一致。使不同员工群体的自主前台活动合法化可能有助于改变组织文化,并逐渐向外传递对透明改进的共同责任。