Mustafa Remsha, Mahboob Usman, Khan Rehan Ahmed, Anjum Abeer
Dr. Remsha Mustafa, MBBS, MHPE. Assistant Professor, Department of Medical Education, Khawaja Muhammad Safdar Medical College, Sialkot, Pakistan.
Dr. Usman Mahboob, MBBS, MPH, FHEA, DHPE, Fellow FAIMER. Associate Professor, Institute of Health Professions Education & Research, Khyber Medical University, Peshawar, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2023 Jan-Feb;39(1):41-45. doi: 10.12669/pjms.39.1.5805.
To explore the problems faced by recent medical graduates in communication with their patients due to language barriers and the influence of these language barriers on the doctor-patient relationship.
A basic qualitative study was conducted at Allama Iqbal Memorial Teaching Hospital Sialkot, Services Hospital Lahore and Mayo Hospital Lahore over eight months after receiving approval from the Ethical Review Board of the University of Lahore. Twelve recent medical graduates from different departments were selected via a purposive sampling technique. Data was collected through semi-structured interviews conducted over the phone with prior appointments. Manual qualitative thematic analysis was done by transcribing the interview and then codes, subthemes, and themes were generated.
Six themes and thirteen subthemes were identified depicting the influence of language barriers on the doctor-patient relationship, namely: frustration (due to repetition, feeling of inadequacy & disappointment), lack of rapport (difficulty in communication, effective counseling & failure in establishment of comfort level), trust Issues (predilection towards the native speaker & difficulty in getting consent) patient dissatisfaction, compliance issues (difficulty in comprehending medication & nature of disease), and threat to patient safety (misdiagnosis & consequent treatment plan & misinterpretation of treatment).
This study establishes the detrimental effects of language barriers on the relationship between physician and patient which can help medical educationists and policymakers in devising a curriculum in such a way that it can minimize the impact of language barriers on the doctor-patient relationship.
探讨近期医学毕业生因语言障碍在与患者沟通时所面临的问题,以及这些语言障碍对医患关系的影响。
在获得拉合尔大学伦理审查委员会批准后,于锡亚尔科特的阿利马·伊克巴尔纪念教学医院、拉合尔服务医院和拉合尔梅奥医院进行了为期八个月的基础定性研究。通过目的抽样技术从不同科室选取了12名近期医学毕业生。通过电话进行预约后进行半结构化访谈收集数据。通过转录访谈内容进行手动定性主题分析,然后生成代码、子主题和主题。
确定了六个主题和十三个子主题,描述了语言障碍对医患关系的影响,即:挫败感(由于重复、能力不足感和失望)、缺乏融洽关系(沟通困难、有效咨询及难以建立舒适感)、信任问题(偏向说母语者及难以获得同意)、患者不满、依从性问题(理解药物和疾病性质困难)以及对患者安全的威胁(误诊及后续治疗计划和对治疗的误解)。
本研究证实了语言障碍对医患关系的有害影响,这有助于医学教育工作者和政策制定者设计课程,以尽量减少语言障碍对医患关系的影响。