Howell Pamella, Abdelhamid Mohamed
Department of Information Systems, California State University Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, United States.
Department of Information Systems, California State University Long Beach, Long Beach, CA, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2023 Mar 1;7:e36608. doi: 10.2196/36608.
Access to data is crucial for decision-making; this fact has become more evident during the pandemic. Data collected using mobile apps can positively influence diagnosis and treatment, the supply chain, and the staffing resources of health care facilities. Developers and health care professionals have worked to create apps that can track a person's COVID-19 status. For example, these apps can monitor positive COVID-19 test results and vaccination status. Regrettably, people may be concerned about sharing their data with government or private sector organizations that are developing apps. Understanding user perceptions is essential; without substantial user adoption and the use of mobile tracing apps, benefits cannot be achieved.
This study aimed to assess the factors that positively and negatively affect the use of COVID-19 tracing apps by examining individuals' perceptions about sharing data on mobile apps, such as testing regularity, infection, and immunization status.
The hypothesized research model was tested using a cross-sectional survey instrument. The survey contained 5 reflective constructs and 4 control variables selected after reviewing the literature and interviewing health care professionals. A digital copy of the survey was created using Qualtrics. After receiving approval, data were collected from 367 participants through Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk). Participants of any gender who were 18 years or older were considered for inclusion to complete the anonymized survey. We then analyzed the theoretical model using structural equation modeling.
After analyzing the quality of responses, 325 participants were included. Of these 325 participants, 216 (66.5%) were male and 109 (33.5%) were female. Among the participants in the final data set, 72.6% (236/325) were employed. The results of structural equation modeling showed that perceived vulnerability (β=0.688; P<.001), self-efficacy (β=0.292; P<.001), and an individual's prior infection with COVID-19 (β=0.194; P=.002) had statistically significant positive impacts on the intention to use mobile tracing apps. Privacy concerns (β=-0.360; P<.001), risk aversion (β=-0.150; P=.09), and a family member's prior infection with COVID-19 (β=-0.139; P=.02) had statistically significant negative influences on a person's intention to use mobile tracing apps.
This study illustrates that various user perceptions affect whether individuals use COVID-19 tracing apps. By working collaboratively on legislation and the messaging provided to potential users before releasing an app, developers, health care professionals, and policymakers can improve the use of tracking apps. Health care professionals need to emphasize disease vulnerability to motivate people to use mobile tracing apps, which can help reduce the spread of viruses and diseases. In addition, more work is needed at the policy-making level to protect the privacy of users, which in return can increase user engagement.
获取数据对于决策至关重要;这一事实在疫情期间变得更加明显。使用移动应用程序收集的数据可以对诊断和治疗、供应链以及医疗保健机构的人员配备资源产生积极影响。开发者和医疗保健专业人员致力于创建能够追踪个人新冠病毒感染状况的应用程序。例如,这些应用程序可以监测新冠病毒检测呈阳性的结果和疫苗接种状况。遗憾的是,人们可能会担心与开发应用程序的政府或私营部门组织分享他们的数据。了解用户认知至关重要;如果没有大量用户采用和使用移动追踪应用程序,就无法实现其益处。
本研究旨在通过考察个人对在移动应用程序上分享数据(如检测频率、感染情况和免疫状况)的认知,评估对新冠病毒追踪应用程序使用产生积极和消极影响的因素。
使用横断面调查工具对假设的研究模型进行测试。该调查包含在查阅文献和采访医疗保健专业人员后选定的5个反映性构念和4个控制变量。使用Qualtrics创建了该调查的数字副本。获得批准后,通过亚马逊土耳其机器人(MTurk)从367名参与者那里收集数据。任何18岁及以上的性别参与者都被纳入以完成匿名调查。然后我们使用结构方程模型分析理论模型。
在分析回复质量后,纳入了325名参与者。在这325名参与者中,216名(66.5%)为男性,109名(33.5%)为女性。在最终数据集中的参与者中,72.6%(236/325)受雇。结构方程模型的结果表明,感知易感性(β = 0.688;P <.001)、自我效能感(β = 0.292;P <.001)以及个人先前感染新冠病毒(β = 0.194;P =.002)对使用移动追踪应用程序的意愿具有统计学上的显著积极影响。隐私担忧(β = -0.360;P <.001)、风险规避(β = -0.150;P =.09)以及家庭成员先前感染新冠病毒(β = -0.139;P =.02)对个人使用移动追踪应用程序的意愿具有统计学上的显著负面影响。
本研究表明,各种用户认知会影响个人是否使用新冠病毒追踪应用程序。通过在立法以及应用程序发布前向潜在用户提供的信息方面进行合作,开发者、医疗保健专业人员和政策制定者可以提高追踪应用程序的使用率。医疗保健专业人员需要强调疾病易感性,以激励人们使用移动追踪应用程序,这有助于减少病毒和疾病的传播。此外,在政策制定层面需要做更多工作来保护用户隐私,这反过来可以提高用户参与度。