Mason Amy M, Obi Ifunanya, Ayodele Olamide, Lambert Samuel A, Fahle Sarah
British Heart Foundation Cardiovascular Epidemiology Unit, Department of Public Health and Primary Care, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Medical Research Council Biostatistics Unit, Cambridge Institute of Public Health, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
J Community Genet. 2023 Oct;14(5):453-458. doi: 10.1007/s12687-023-00635-1. Epub 2023 Feb 10.
The aim of this patient and public involvement and engagement (PPIE) work was to explore improvised theatre as a tool for facilitating bi-directional dialogue between researchers and patients/members of the public on the topic of polygenic risk scores (PRS) use within primary or secondary care. PRS are a tool to quantify genetic risk for a heritable disease or trait and may be used to predict future health outcomes. In the United Kingdom (UK), they are often cited as a next-in-line public health tool to be implemented, and their use in consumer genetic testing as well as patient-facing settings is increasing. Despite their potential clinical utility, broader themes about how they might influence an individual's perception of disease risk and decision-making are an active area of research; however, this has mostly been in the setting of return of results to patients. We worked with a youth theatre group and patients involved in a PPIE group to develop two short plays about public perceptions of genetic risk information that could be captured by PRS. These plays were shared in a workshop with patients/members of the public to facilitate discussions about PRS and their perceived benefits, concerns and emotional reactions. Discussions with both performers and patients/public raised three key questions: (1) can the data be trusted?; (2) does knowing genetic risk actually help the patient?; and (3) what makes a life worthwhile? Creating and watching fictional narratives helped all participants explore the potential use of PRS in a clinical setting, informing future research considerations and improving communication between the researchers and lay members of the PPIE group.
这项患者及公众参与和介入(PPIE)工作的目的是探索即兴戏剧作为一种工具,以促进研究人员与患者/公众之间就初级或二级医疗中多基因风险评分(PRS)的使用这一主题进行双向对话。PRS是一种量化遗传性疾病或性状遗传风险的工具,可用于预测未来的健康结果。在英国,它们常被视为即将实施的下一个公共卫生工具,并且在消费者基因检测以及面向患者的环境中的使用正在增加。尽管它们具有潜在的临床效用,但关于它们如何可能影响个体对疾病风险的认知和决策的更广泛主题仍是一个活跃的研究领域;然而,这大多是在向患者反馈检测结果的背景下进行的。我们与一个青年戏剧团体以及参与PPIE小组的患者合作,创作了两部关于公众对可由PRS捕捉的基因风险信息认知的短剧。这些短剧在一个与患者/公众共同参与的研讨会上进行了分享,以促进关于PRS及其感知到的益处、担忧和情绪反应的讨论。与表演者以及患者/公众的讨论提出了三个关键问题:(1)数据可信吗?;(2)了解基因风险真的对患者有帮助吗?;以及(3)什么让生命有价值?创作和观看虚构的叙事帮助所有参与者探索了PRS在临床环境中的潜在用途,为未来的研究考量提供了信息,并改善了研究人员与PPIE小组外行人之间的沟通。