Zhou Wei, Wang Zehua, Han Feifei, Hong Liu
Department of Digestive Surgery, The First Affiliated Hospital, Air Force Medical University, 127 Changle West Road, Xi'an, 710032, China.
School of Foreign Languages, Shaanxi Xueqian Normal University, Shenhe 2nd Road, Xi'an, 710100, China.
Heliyon. 2023 Feb;9(2):e13434. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e13434. Epub 2023 Feb 4.
Gastrointestinal clinical teaching is of vital important for gastrointestinal surgery interns. However, during COVID-19 pandemic, due to frequent lockdowns and essential social distancing policy implemented in China, face-to-face teaching was interrupted significantly. To find a cost-effective way to deliver medical education to ensure that teaching and learning would be continued and uninterrupted, many social media tools and mobile applications have been used in medical teaching and learning. WeChat has been frequently employed in teaching and learning in many disciplines in Chinese universities due to its powerful functions and free cost. This study compared Chinese digestive surgery interns' learning quality, English reading proficiency, and learning satisfaction in two teaching conditions: the traditional face-to-face teaching versus WeChat teaching via an experiment. The study recruited 60 final year clinical medical students, who were randomly and equally assigned into two groups: traditional face-to-face teaching versus WeChat teaching. Interns' learning quality and learning satisfaction were measured by Likert-scale questionnaires; and their English reading proficiency was measured by the reading section in a standardized English test. The results showed that interns in WeChat group had significantly higher learning quality on understanding mechanisms and current knowledge by both self-assessment and peer-assessment. WeChat group also outperformed face-to-face group on inferencing, details, and main ideas in English reading. With regard to learning satisfaction, WeChat group were higher on learning interests, learning objectives, learning format, and English reading proficiency than face-to-face group. However, interns did not differ in terms of their learning satisfaction on medical skills, which might indicate that WeChat had limitations on training interns' medical practical ability.
胃肠临床教学对胃肠外科实习生至关重要。然而,在新冠疫情期间,由于中国频繁实施封锁和必要的社交距离政策,面对面教学受到显著干扰。为找到一种经济高效的医学教育方式,以确保教学能够持续且不间断,许多社交媒体工具和移动应用已被用于医学教学。微信因其强大功能和免费特性,在中国高校的多学科教学中被频繁使用。本研究通过一项实验,比较了中国消化外科实习生在两种教学条件下的学习质量、英语阅读能力和学习满意度:传统面对面教学与微信教学。该研究招募了60名临床医学生,他们被随机且平均分为两组:传统面对面教学组和微信教学组。实习生的学习质量和学习满意度通过李克特量表问卷进行测量;他们的英语阅读能力通过标准化英语测试的阅读部分进行测量。结果表明,微信组实习生在通过自我评估和同伴评估理解机制和当前知识方面的学习质量显著更高。在英语阅读的推理、细节和主旨方面,微信组也优于面对面教学组。在学习满意度方面,微信组在学习兴趣、学习目标、学习形式和英语阅读能力方面高于面对面教学组。然而,实习生在医疗技能的学习满意度方面没有差异,这可能表明微信在培训实习生医疗实践能力方面存在局限性。