Shimada Daishi, Sagawa Motoyasu, Seki Masafumi
Division of Infectious Diseases, Tohoku Medical and Pharmaceutical University Hospital, Sendai City, Japan.
Division of Endoscopy, Tohoku Medical and Pharmaceutical University Hospital, Sendai City, Japan.
Infect Drug Resist. 2023 Feb 17;16:977-984. doi: 10.2147/IDR.S400200. eCollection 2023.
Higher rates of diagnosis of pulmonary (MAC) disease by bronchoscopy (BS) in patients who could not diagnose by sputum cultures have been suggested, but the detailed utility of BS, especially in combination with anti-glycopeptidolipid-core IgA antibodies (anti-MAC Ab), is still unclear.
A total of 111 patients at our hospital with suspected MAC who underwent BS because they were sputum-negative from April 2018 to March 2022 were analyzed prospectively. These patients were also divided into two groups, anti-MAC Ab-positive and anti-MAC Ab-negative, and compared.
A total of 111 patients underwent BS, though 95 (38.0%) of 250 enrolled patients were sputum smear/culture-positive. The age of the 111 patients was 69.14 (31.0-89.0) years, and 90 (81.0%) were female; 69 (62.2%) of 111 patients were either smear-positive (n = 42, 37.8%) or culture-positive (n = 27, 24.3%) by BS. Of the total 111 patients, 69 (62.2%) were anti-MAC Ab-positive and 57 (82.6%) of 69 patients were also positive by BS. In contrast, only 12 (28.6%) of the 42 anti-MAC Ab-negative patients were positive by BS. The sensitivity and specificity of anti-MAC Ab for positive by BS were 82.6% and 71.4%, respectively, and the area under the curve (AUC) on receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was 0.807.
BS and anti-MAC Ab showed similar usefulness to confirm the diagnosis in patients who could not be diagnosed by sputum examination, but pulmonary MAC disease was strongly suspected based on chest radiography/CT findings. These two examinations were correlated, and their combination appeared to provide more accurate diagnosis and earlier therapy.
对于痰培养无法确诊的患者,支气管镜检查(BS)诊断肺部(MAC)疾病的比例较高,但支气管镜检查的详细效用,尤其是与抗糖脂核心IgA抗体(抗MAC Ab)联合使用时,仍不明确。
对我院2018年4月至2022年3月期间因痰检阴性而接受支气管镜检查的111例疑似MAC患者进行前瞻性分析。这些患者也被分为抗MAC Ab阳性和抗MAC Ab阴性两组,并进行比较。
共有111例患者接受了支气管镜检查,尽管250例纳入患者中有95例(38.0%)痰涂片/培养呈阳性。111例患者的年龄为69.14(31.0 - 89.0)岁,90例(81.0%)为女性;111例患者中有69例(62.2%)支气管镜检查涂片阳性(n = 42,37.8%)或培养阳性(n = 27,24.3%)。在总共111例患者中,69例(62.2%)抗MAC Ab阳性,69例患者中有57例(82.6%)支气管镜检查也呈阳性。相比之下,42例抗MAC Ab阴性患者中只有12例(28.6%)支气管镜检查呈阳性。抗MAC Ab对支气管镜检查阳性的敏感性和特异性分别为82.6%和71.4%,在受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线分析中的曲线下面积(AUC)为0.807。
支气管镜检查和抗MAC Ab在痰检无法确诊但基于胸部X线/CT表现高度怀疑肺部MAC疾病的患者中,在确诊方面显示出相似的效用。这两项检查具有相关性,联合使用似乎能提供更准确的诊断和更早的治疗。