Gillian K. SteelFisher, Harvard University, Boston, Massachusetts.
Mary G. Findling (
Health Aff (Millwood). 2023 Mar;42(3):328-337. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2022.01204.
Public health agencies' ability to protect health in the wake of COVID-19 largely depends on public trust. In February 2022 we conducted a first-of-its-kind nationally representative survey of 4,208 US adults to learn the public's reported reasons for trust in federal, state, and local public health agencies. Among respondents who expressed a "great deal" of trust, that trust was not related primarily to agencies' ability to control the spread of COVID-19 but, rather, to beliefs that those agencies made clear, science-based recommendations and provided protective resources. Scientific expertise was a more commonly reported reason for "a great deal" of trust at the federal level, whereas perceptions of hard work, compassionate policy, and direct services were emphasized more at the state and local levels. Although trust in public health agencies was not especially high, few respondents indicated that they had no trust. Lower trust was related primarily to respondents' beliefs that health recommendations were politically influenced and inconsistent. The least trusting respondents also endorsed concerns about private-sector influence and excessive restrictions and had low trust in government overall. Our findings suggest the need to support a robust federal, state, and local public health communications infrastructure; ensure agencies' authority to make science-based recommendations; and develop strategies for engaging different segments of the public.
公共卫生机构在 COVID-19 之后保护健康的能力在很大程度上取决于公众的信任。2022 年 2 月,我们对 4208 名美国成年人进行了首次全国代表性调查,以了解公众对联邦、州和地方公共卫生机构的信任报告原因。在表示“非常信任”的受访者中,这种信任主要不是基于机构控制 COVID-19 传播的能力,而是基于这些机构提出明确、基于科学的建议并提供保护资源的信念。在联邦层面,科学专业知识是“非常信任”的一个更常见的报告原因,而在州和地方层面,更多强调的是对工作努力、富有同情心的政策和直接服务的看法。尽管对公共卫生机构的信任度不是特别高,但很少有受访者表示他们不信任。较低的信任度主要与受访者认为健康建议受到政治影响和不一致有关。最不信任的受访者也赞同对私营部门影响和过度限制的担忧,并对政府整体缺乏信任。我们的研究结果表明,有必要支持强大的联邦、州和地方公共卫生沟通基础设施;确保机构有权提出基于科学的建议;并制定策略来吸引公众的不同群体。