Jeboda Dammy, Shackelford Brandie Banner, Chigwechokha Petros, Chunga Brighton A, Ercumen Ayse, Workman Cassandra, Hart Joy L, Smith Ted, Holm Rochelle H
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, College of Arts and Sciences, University of Louisville, Louisville, Kentucky.
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, Lilongwe, Malawi.
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2025 May 13;113(1):200-213. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.24-0759. Print 2025 Jul 2.
Across low- and middle-income countries, there have been calls to expand wastewater and environmental surveillance to include non-sewered sanitation systems. Considering public opinion, understanding, and acceptance, as well as any related privacy and personal health information concerns, is important in this context. This study used an in-person survey to learn more about the perceptions of Malawian and Malawi refugee camp residents regarding wastewater and environmental surveillance as public health tools, as well as their views on privacy and personal health information. A 15-question survey was conducted from May to July 2024 at three locations in northern, central, and southern Malawi, including a refugee camp (N = 536). Some respondents (n = 30) also completed a board game and a post-game survey. The results indicated high public support for surveilling communicable diseases, deadly diseases, environmental toxicants, healthy eating, illegal drugs, mental illnesses, and prescription drugs. Respondents were less supportive of surveillance that might expose their lifestyle behaviors and alcohol use. Regarding sampling locations, the surveillance of an entire city or of camps and schools had the highest acceptance. Some opposition to surveillance in business and religious organizations was noted. If surveilled, respondents wanted the results of the data analysis to be communicated back to them. Our findings suggested that Malawian and Malawi camp residents supported, with little concern, ongoing wastewater and environmental surveillance for public health. Considering privacy thresholds and participant autonomy regarding public health surveillance tools, along with cultural relevance, is important for future policy development and investment.
在低收入和中等收入国家,人们呼吁扩大废水和环境监测范围,将无下水道卫生系统纳入其中。在这种情况下,考虑公众意见、理解和接受程度,以及任何相关的隐私和个人健康信息问题非常重要。本研究通过面对面调查,进一步了解马拉维和马拉维难民营居民对废水和环境监测作为公共卫生工具的看法,以及他们对隐私和个人健康信息的观点。2024年5月至7月,在马拉维北部、中部和南部的三个地点(包括一个难民营)开展了一项包含15个问题的调查(N = 536)。部分受访者(n = 30)还完成了一款棋盘游戏及游戏后的调查。结果显示,公众高度支持对传染病、致命疾病、环境毒物、健康饮食、非法药物、精神疾病和处方药进行监测。受访者对可能暴露其生活方式行为和饮酒情况的监测支持度较低。关于采样地点,对整个城市或营地及学校进行监测的接受度最高。有人指出对商业和宗教组织进行监测存在一些反对意见。如果接受监测,受访者希望能得知数据分析结果。我们的研究结果表明,马拉维和马拉维难民营居民对持续开展的用于公共卫生的废水和环境监测几乎没有顾虑地表示支持。在未来的政策制定和投资中,考虑公共卫生监测工具的隐私阈值和参与者自主权以及文化相关性非常重要。