Williams Soraya, Jalal Aveen R, Lewis Mark P, Davies Owen G
School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences, Loughborough University, Loughborough, UK.
J Tissue Eng. 2023 Mar 8;14:20417314231155114. doi: 10.1177/20417314231155114. eCollection 2023 Jan-Dec.
Extracellular vesicles (EVs) continue to gain interest across the scientific community for diagnostic and therapeutic applications. As EV applications diversify, it is essential that researchers are aware of challenges, in particular the compatibility of EV isolation methods with downstream applications and their clinical translation. We report outcomes of the first cross-comparison study looking to determine parameters (EV source, starting volume, operator experience, application and implementation parameters such as cost and scalability) governing the selection of popular EV isolation methods across disciplines. Our findings highlighted an increased clinical focus, with 36% of respondents applying EVs in therapeutics and diagnostics. Data indicated preferential selection of ultracentrifugation for therapeutic applications, precipitation reagents in clinical settings and size exclusion chromatography for diagnostic applications utilising biofluids. Method selection was influenced by operator experience, with increased method diversity when EV research was not the respondents primary focus. Application and implementation criteria were indicated to be major influencers in method selection, with UC and SEC chosen for their abilities to process large and small volumes, respectively. Overall, we identified parameters influencing method selection across the breadth of EV science, providing a valuable overview of practical considerations for the effective translation of research outcomes.
细胞外囊泡(EVs)在诊断和治疗应用方面持续受到科学界的关注。随着EV应用的多样化,研究人员必须意识到其中的挑战,尤其是EV分离方法与下游应用及其临床转化的兼容性。我们报告了第一项交叉比较研究的结果,该研究旨在确定跨学科选择常用EV分离方法的参数(EV来源、起始体积、操作人员经验、应用和实施参数,如成本和可扩展性)。我们的研究结果突出了临床关注度的提高,36%的受访者将EVs应用于治疗和诊断。数据表明,治疗应用优先选择超速离心法,临床环境中选择沉淀试剂,利用生物流体进行诊断应用时选择尺寸排阻色谱法。方法的选择受操作人员经验的影响,当EV研究不是受访者的主要关注点时,方法的多样性会增加。应用和实施标准被认为是方法选择的主要影响因素,超速离心法和尺寸排阻色谱法分别因其处理大量和小体积样品的能力而被选用。总体而言,我们确定了影响EV科学各个领域方法选择的参数,为有效转化研究成果的实际考量提供了有价值的概述。