Graduate School of Arts and Social Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
J Hist Neurosci. 2023 Jul-Sep;32(3):357-372. doi: 10.1080/0964704X.2023.2179406. Epub 2023 Mar 17.
The famous discussion of Scythian cross-dressers in Hippocrates' (.) 22 puzzled perhaps most medieval and Renaissance medical authorities. The text wrestled with a pre-Hippocratic, encephalocentric theory of spermatogenesis. Modern reception of the convoluted hypothesis put forward here gradually distilled three etiologies of failing virility: impotence, subfertility, and unmanliness. A gradual shift is discernable from increasingly Galenic neuro-andrological theories (sixteenth century) to neuropsychiatric (late-seventeenth through eighteenth century), phrenological and psychopathological (early- and late-nineteenth century), and finally early psycho-endocrinological (early-twentieth century) ideas about masculinity. . 22 was a ubiquitously recurring reference across all of these episodes, indeed well beyond medicine, rendering it a highly sensitive index of change in neurodevelopmental and neuropsychiatric thinking. The pre-Enlightenment, neurology-centric onset of this extended modern history of sexual/gender medicine is briefly discussed, as well as its phrenological afterlife.
希波克拉底(Hippocrates)的著作中对斯基泰(Scythian)异装癖者的著名讨论或许让最多的中世纪和文艺复兴时期的医学权威感到困惑。这段文字与前希波克拉底时代、以大脑为中心的精子发生理论相冲突。这里提出的复杂假设在现代逐渐被归纳为三种导致男性生育力下降的病因:阳痿、不育和不男子气概。从越来越多的盖伦(Galenic)神经和神经病学理论(十六世纪)到神经精神病理学(十七世纪晚期到十八世纪)、颅相学和精神病理学(十九世纪早期和晚期),再到早期的心理内分泌学(二十世纪早期)关于男性气质的观念,人们可以明显看出这种转变。第 22 章在所有这些事件中都是普遍反复出现的参考,实际上远不止医学领域,它是神经发育和神经精神思维变化的一个高度敏感的指标。本文简要讨论了这一贯穿整个现代性医学史的以神经学为中心的、前启蒙时代的观点,以及其颅相学的后续影响。