Kühn Lukas, Lindert Lara, Kuper Paulina, Choi Kyung-Eun Anna
Center for Health Services Research, Brandenburg Medical School, Rüdersdorf bei Berlin, Germany.
Medical Image Analysis & Artificial Intelligence Research Centre, Health Services Research Group, Danube Private University, Krems-Stein, Austria.
JMIR Rehabil Assist Technol. 2023 Apr 13;10:e39512. doi: 10.2196/39512.
The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic impacted access to inpatient rehabilitation services. At the current state of research, it is unclear to what extent the adaptation of rehabilitation services to infection-protective standards affected patient-centered care in Germany.
The aim of this study was to determine the most relevant aspects of patient-centered care for patients in inpatient rehabilitation clinics under early phase pandemic conditions.
A deductive-inductive framework analysis of online patient reports posted on a leading German hospital rating website, Klinikbewertungen (Clinic Reviews), was performed. This website is a third-party, patient-centered commercial platform that operates independently of governmental entities. Following a theoretical sampling approach, online reports of rehabilitation stays in two federal states of Germany (Brandenburg and Saarland) uploaded between March 2020 and September 2021 were included. Independent of medical specialty groups, all reports were included. Keywords addressing framework domains were analyzed descriptively.
In total, 649 online reports reflecting inpatient rehabilitation services of 31 clinics (Brandenburg, n=23; Saarland, n=8) were analyzed. Keywords addressing the care environment were most frequently reported (59.9%), followed by staff prerequisites (33.0%), patient-centered processes (4.5%), and expected outcomes (2.6%). Qualitative in-depth analysis revealed SARS-CoV-2-related reports to be associated with domains of patient-centered processes and staff prerequisites. Discontinuous communication of infection protection standards was perceived to threaten patient autonomy. This was amplified by a tangible gratification crisis of medical staff. Established and emotional supportive relationships to clinicians and peer groups offered the potential to mitigate the adverse effects of infection protection standards.
Patients predominantly reported feedback associated with the care environment. SARS-CoV-2-related reports were strongly affected by increased staff workloads as well as patient-centered processes addressing discontinuous communication and organizationally demanding implementation of infection protection standards, which were perceived to threaten patient autonomy. Peer relationships formed during inpatient rehabilitation had the potential to mitigate these mechanisms.
严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)大流行影响了住院康复服务的可及性。在当前的研究状态下,尚不清楚德国康复服务对感染防护标准的调整在多大程度上影响了以患者为中心的护理。
本研究的目的是确定在大流行早期阶段,住院康复诊所中以患者为中心的护理最相关的方面。
对德国一家领先的医院评级网站Klinikbewertungen(诊所评价)上发布的在线患者报告进行了演绎-归纳框架分析。该网站是一个以患者为中心的第三方商业平台,独立于政府实体运营。采用理论抽样方法,纳入了2020年3月至2021年9月期间在德国两个联邦州(勃兰登堡州和萨尔兰州)上传的康复住院在线报告。所有报告均纳入,不考虑医学专科组。对涉及框架领域的关键词进行了描述性分析。
共分析了反映31家诊所(勃兰登堡州,n = 23;萨尔兰州,n = 8)住院康复服务的649份在线报告。涉及护理环境的关键词报告最为频繁(59.9%),其次是工作人员要求(33.0%)、以患者为中心的流程(4.5%)和预期结果(2.6%)。定性深入分析显示,与SARS-CoV-2相关的报告与以患者为中心的流程和工作人员要求领域相关。感染防护标准的不连续沟通被认为会威胁患者自主权。医务人员明显的满足感危机加剧了这种情况。与临床医生和同伴群体建立的情感支持关系有可能减轻感染防护标准的不利影响。
患者主要报告了与护理环境相关的反馈。与SARS-CoV-2相关的报告受到工作人员工作量增加以及以患者为中心的流程的强烈影响,这些流程涉及不连续沟通以及组织上要求实施感染防护标准,而这些被认为会威胁患者自主权。住院康复期间形成的同伴关系有可能减轻这些影响机制。