Khan Aslam, Ndenga Bryson, Mutuku Francis, Bosire Carren M, Okuta Victoria, Ronga Charles O, Mutai Noah K, Musaki Sandra K, Chebii Philip K, Maina Priscilla W, Jembe Zainab, Amugongo Jael S, Malumbo Said L, Ng'ang'a Charles M, LaBeaud Desiree
Department of Pediatrics, Division of Infectious Diseases, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California, United States of America.
Centre for Global Health Research, Kenya Medical Research Institute, Kisumu, Kenya.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2022 Apr 20;2(4):e0000175. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0000175. eCollection 2022.
From 1975-2009, the WHO guidelines classified symptomatic dengue virus infections as dengue fever, dengue hemorrhagic fever, and dengue shock syndrome. In 2009 the case definition was changed to a clinical classification after concern the original criteria was challenging to apply in resource-limited settings and not inclusive of a substantial proportion of severe dengue cases. Our goal was to examine how well the current WHO definition identified new dengue cases at our febrile surveillance sites in Kenya. Between 2014 and 2019 as part of a child cohort study of febrile illness in our four clinical study sites (Ukunda, Kisumu, Msambweni, Chulaimbo) we identified 369 dengue PCR positive symptomatic cases and characterized whether they met the 2009 revised WHO diagnostic criteria for dengue with and without warning signs and severe dengue. We found 62% of our PCR-confirmed dengue cases did not meet criteria per the guidelines. Our findings also correlate with our experience that dengue disease in children in Kenya is less severe as reported in other parts of the world. Although the 2009 clinical classification has recently been criticized for being overly inclusive and non-specific, our findings suggest the 2009 WHO dengue case definition may miss more than 50% of symptomatic infections in Kenya and may require further modification to include the African experience.
从1975年至2009年,世界卫生组织(WHO)的指南将有症状的登革病毒感染分为登革热、登革出血热和登革休克综合征。2009年,由于担心原标准在资源有限的环境中难以应用,且未涵盖相当比例的严重登革热病例,病例定义改为临床分类。我们的目标是研究WHO目前的定义在肯尼亚发热监测点识别新登革热病例的效果如何。2014年至2019年期间,作为我们在四个临床研究地点(乌昆达、基苏木、姆桑布韦尼、楚莱姆博)对发热疾病进行的儿童队列研究的一部分,我们识别出369例登革热PCR检测呈阳性的有症状病例,并确定他们是否符合2009年修订的WHO登革热诊断标准,包括有无警示体征以及是否为严重登革热。我们发现,62%经PCR确诊的登革热病例不符合指南标准。我们的研究结果也与我们的经验相符,即肯尼亚儿童的登革热病情不如世界其他地区报道的严重。尽管2009年的临床分类最近因过于宽泛和缺乏特异性而受到批评,但我们的研究结果表明,2009年WHO的登革热病例定义可能会遗漏肯尼亚超过50%的有症状感染病例,可能需要进一步修订以纳入非洲的情况。