Lesic Vedran, de Bruin Wändi Bruine, Davis Matthew C, Krishnamurti Tamar, Azevedo Inês M L
Centre for Decision Research, Leeds University Business School, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, United Kingdom.
Department of Engineering and Public Policy, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, United States of America.
Environ Res Lett. 2018 Mar;13(3). doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/aaab92. Epub 2018 Mar 6.
Policy makers and program managers need to better understand consumers' perceptions of their energy use and savings to design effective strategies for promoting energy savings.
We reviewed 14 studies from the emerging interdisciplinary literature examining consumers' perceptions electricity use by specific appliances, and potential savings.
We find that: (1) electricity use is often overestimated for low-energy consuming appliances, and underestimated for high-energy consuming appliances; (2) curtailment strategies are typically preferred over energy efficiency strategies; (3) consumers lack information about how much electricity can be saved through specific strategies; (4) consumers use heuristics for assessing the electricity use of specific appliances, with some indication that more accurate judgments are made among consumers with higher numeracy and stronger pro-environmental attitudes. However, design differences between studies, such as variations in reference points, reporting units and assessed time periods, may affect consumers' reported perceptions. Moreover, studies differ with regard to whether accuracy of perceptions was evaluated through comparisons with general estimates of actual use, self-reported use, household-level meter readings, or real-time smart meter readings.
Although emerging findings are promising, systematic variations in the measurement of perceived and actual electricity use are potential cause for concern. We propose avenues for future research, so as to better understand, and possibly inform, consumers' perceptions of their electricity use. Ultimately, this literature will have implications for the design of effective electricity feedback for consumers, and related policies.
政策制定者和项目管理者需要更好地了解消费者对其能源使用和节能情况的认知,以便设计出有效的节能推广策略。
我们回顾了新兴跨学科文献中的14项研究,这些研究考察了消费者对特定电器用电情况以及潜在节能效果的认知。
我们发现:(1)对于低能耗电器,用电量往往被高估,而对于高能耗电器,用电量则往往被低估;(2)与能源效率策略相比,削减策略通常更受青睐;(3)消费者缺乏关于通过特定策略可节省多少电量的信息;(4)消费者使用启发式方法来评估特定电器的用电量,有迹象表明,在算术能力较强且环保态度更坚定的消费者中,判断更为准确。然而,研究之间的设计差异,如参考点、报告单位和评估时间段的变化,可能会影响消费者报告的认知。此外,关于认知准确性是通过与实际使用的一般估计、自我报告的使用情况、家庭层面的电表读数还是实时智能电表读数进行比较来评估,研究之间也存在差异。
尽管新出现的研究结果很有前景,但感知用电量和实际用电量测量中的系统差异可能令人担忧。我们提出了未来研究的方向,以便更好地理解并可能告知消费者对其用电量的认知。最终,这些文献将对为消费者设计有效的用电反馈及相关政策产生影响。