Primary Health Care of the Capital Area, Iceland.
Department of Computer Science, Reykjavik University, Reykjavík, Iceland.
Ann Fam Med. 2023 May-Jun;21(3):240-248. doi: 10.1370/afm.2970.
Respiratory symptoms are the most common presenting complaint in primary care. Often these symptoms are self resolving, but they can indicate a severe illness. With increasing physician workload and health care costs, triaging patients before in-person consultations would be helpful, possibly offering low-risk patients other means of communication. The objective of this study was to train a machine learning model to triage patients with respiratory symptoms before visiting a primary care clinic and examine patient outcomes in the context of the triage.
We trained a machine learning model, using clinical features only available before a medical visit. Clinical text notes were extracted from 1,500 records for patients that received 1 of 7 codes (J00, J10, JII, J15, J20, J44, J45). All primary care clinics in the Reykjavík area of Iceland were included. The model scored patients in 2 extrinsic data sets and divided them into 10 risk groups (higher values having greater risk). We analyzed selected outcomes in each group.
Risk groups 1 through 5 consisted of younger patients with lower C-reactive protein values, re-evaluation rates in primary and emergency care, antibiotic prescription rates, chest x-ray (CXR) referrals, and CXRs with signs of pneumonia, compared with groups 6 through 10. Groups 1 through 5 had no CXRs with signs of pneumonia or diagnosis of pneumonia by a physician.
The model triaged patients in line with expected outcomes. The model can reduce the number of CXR referrals by eliminating them in risk groups 1 through 5, thus decreasing clinically insignificant incidentaloma findings without input from clinicians.
呼吸症状是初级保健中最常见的就诊主诉。这些症状通常会自行缓解,但也可能表明病情严重。随着医生工作量和医疗保健成本的增加,在面对面咨询之前对患者进行分诊将有所帮助,这可能为低风险患者提供其他沟通方式。本研究的目的是训练机器学习模型,以便在患者前往初级保健诊所之前对其进行分诊,并在分诊的背景下检查患者的结局。
我们使用就诊前仅可获得的临床特征来训练机器学习模型。从接受以下 7 个代码之一(J00、J10、JII、J15、J20、J44、J45)的 1500 名患者的记录中提取临床文本注释。冰岛雷克雅未克地区的所有初级保健诊所均包含在内。该模型在 2 个外部数据集上对患者进行评分,并将其分为 10 个风险组(分值越高,风险越大)。我们分析了每个组中的选定结局。
风险组 1 至 5 由年轻患者和较低的 C 反应蛋白值组成,在初级保健和急诊中再次评估的比例、抗生素处方率、胸部 X 光(CXR)转诊率以及 CXR 有肺炎迹象的比例均低于风险组 6 至 10。风险组 1 至 5 中没有 CXR 有肺炎迹象或医生诊断为肺炎。
该模型的分诊与预期结局一致。通过在风险组 1 至 5 中消除 CXR 转诊,可以减少 CXR 转诊数量,从而减少无临床意义的偶然发现,而无需临床医生的投入。