Wong Aaron K, Somogyi Andrew A, Rubio Justin, Pham Tien Dung, Le Brian, Klepstad Pal, Philip Jennifer
Department of Palliative Care, Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre, Melbourne 3052, Australia.
Department of Palliative Care, The Royal Melbourne Hospital, Melbourne 3050, Australia.
Cancers (Basel). 2023 Jul 19;15(14):3676. doi: 10.3390/cancers15143676.
Opioid switching is a common practice of substituting one opioid for another to improve analgesia or adverse effects; however, it has limited evidence. This study aimed to examine the effectiveness of opioid switching in advanced cancer. This multi-center prospective cohort study recruited patients assessed to switch opioids (opioid switch group) or to continue ongoing opioid treatment (control group). Clinical data (demographics, opioids) and validated instruments (pain and adverse effects) were collected over two timepoints seven days apart. Descriptive analyses were utilized. Non-parametric tests were used to determine differences. Fifty-four participants were recruited (23 control group, 31 switch group). At the follow-up, opioid switching reduced pain (worst, average, and now) ( < 0.05), uncontrolled breakthrough pain (3-fold reduction, = 0.008), and psychological distress (48% to 16%, < 0.005). The switch group had a ≥25% reduction in the reported frequency of seven moderate-to-severe adverse effects (score ≥ 4), compared to a reduction in only one adverse effect in the control group. The control group experienced no significant pain differences at the follow-up. Opioid switching is effective at reducing pain, adverse effects, and psychological distress in a population with advanced cancer pain, to levels of satisfactory symptom control in most patients within 1 week.
阿片类药物转换是一种用一种阿片类药物替代另一种以改善镇痛效果或不良反应的常见做法;然而,其证据有限。本研究旨在检验阿片类药物转换在晚期癌症患者中的有效性。这项多中心前瞻性队列研究招募了被评估为要转换阿片类药物的患者(阿片类药物转换组)或继续进行现有阿片类药物治疗的患者(对照组)。在相隔7天的两个时间点收集临床数据(人口统计学、阿片类药物)和经过验证的工具(疼痛和不良反应)。采用描述性分析。使用非参数检验来确定差异。共招募了54名参与者(23名对照组,31名转换组)。在随访时,阿片类药物转换减轻了疼痛(最严重、平均和当前疼痛)(P<0.05)、未控制的爆发性疼痛(降低了3倍,P = 0.008)以及心理困扰(从48%降至16%,P<0.005)。转换组报告的七种中度至重度不良反应(评分≥4)的发生频率降低了≥25%,而对照组仅一种不良反应有所减少。对照组在随访时疼痛无显著差异。阿片类药物转换在减轻晚期癌症疼痛患者的疼痛、不良反应和心理困扰方面有效,能在1周内将大多数患者的症状控制在满意水平。