Healthy High Density Cities Lab, HKUrbanLab, The University of Hong Kong, Knowles Building, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
Department of Urban Planning and Design, Faculty of Architecture, The University of Hong Kong, Knowles Building, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
J Urban Health. 2023 Aug;100(4):745-787. doi: 10.1007/s11524-023-00764-5. Epub 2023 Aug 14.
With rapid urbanization, built environment has emerged as a set of modifiable factors of cardiovascular disease (CVD) risks. We conducted a systematic review to synthesize evidence on the associations of attributes of urban built environment (e.g. residential density, land use mix, greenness and walkability) with cardiovascular risk factors (e.g. hypertension and arterial stiffness) and major CVD events including mortality. A total of 63 studies, including 31 of cross-sectional design and 32 of longitudinal design conducted across 21 geographical locations and published between 2012 and 2023 were extracted for review. Overall, we report moderately consistent evidence of protective associations of greenness with cardiovascular risks and major CVD events (cross-sectional studies: 12 of 15 on hypertension/blood pressure (BP) and 2 of 3 on arterial stiffness; and longitudinal studies: 6 of 8 on hypertension/BP, 7 of 8 on CVD mortality, 3 of 3 on ischemic heart disease mortality and 5 of 8 studies on stroke hospitalization or mortality reporting significant inverse associations). Consistently, walkability was associated with lower risks of hypertension, arterial stiffness and major CVD events (cross-sectional studies: 11 of 12 on hypertension/BP and 1 of 1 on arterial stiffness; and longitudinal studies: 3 of 6 on hypertension/BP and 1 of 2 studies on CVD events being protective). Sixty-seven percent of the studies were rated as "probably high" risk of confounding bias because of inability to adjust for underlying comorbidities/family history of diseases in their statistical models. Forty-six percent and 14% of the studies were rated as "probably high" risk of bias for exposure and outcome measurements, respectively. Future studies with robust design will further help elucidate the linkages between urban built environment and cardiovascular health, thereby informing planning policies for creating healthy cities.
随着城市化的快速发展,建成环境已成为心血管疾病(CVD)风险的一系列可改变因素。我们进行了一项系统评价,以综合有关城市建成环境属性(例如居住密度、土地利用混合、绿化和可步行性)与心血管危险因素(例如高血压和动脉僵硬)以及包括死亡率在内的主要 CVD 事件之间关联的证据。共有 63 项研究,包括 31 项横断面设计和 32 项纵向设计,在 21 个地理位置进行,发表时间在 2012 年至 2023 年之间,被提取用于审查。总体而言,我们报告了绿化与心血管风险和主要 CVD 事件之间存在保护关联的证据,这些证据具有中等一致性(横断面研究:15 项关于高血压/血压(BP)的研究中有 12 项,3 项关于动脉僵硬的研究中有 2 项;纵向研究:8 项关于高血压/BP 的研究中有 6 项,8 项关于 CVD 死亡率的研究中有 7 项,3 项关于缺血性心脏病死亡率的研究中有 3 项,8 项关于中风住院或死亡率的研究中有 5 项报告了显著的负相关)。可步行性与较低的高血压、动脉僵硬和主要 CVD 事件风险相关(横断面研究:12 项关于高血压/BP 的研究中有 11 项,1 项关于动脉僵硬的研究中有 1 项;纵向研究:6 项关于高血压/BP 的研究中有 3 项,2 项关于 CVD 事件的研究中有 1 项具有保护作用)。由于其统计模型无法调整潜在的合并症/疾病家族史,因此 67%的研究被评为“可能存在高”混杂偏倚风险。46%和 14%的研究分别被评为“可能存在高”暴露和结局测量偏倚风险。具有稳健设计的未来研究将进一步有助于阐明城市建成环境与心血管健康之间的联系,从而为创建健康城市提供规划政策信息。