Faculty of Health Science of Trairi, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Santa Cruz, Brazil.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Health Expect. 2023 Dec;26(6):2500-2513. doi: 10.1111/hex.13717. Epub 2023 Aug 18.
In Brazil, more than 3500 children with congenital Zika syndrome (CZS) face difficulties participating in activities of daily living, which may be aggravated by health emergencies, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Participation could be defined as the individual's involvement in daily life situations, and participation restrictions are problems that may arise in involvement in everyday situations.
To explore the daily lives of children with CZS during the COVID-19 pandemic using photographic narratives captured by mothers and discuss possible strategies to improve participation results.
In this participatory action research, seven young Brazilian mothers acted as co-researchers using photovoice to describe the experiences of their children with CZS (from 2 to 5 years old). Also, mothers contributed to validate the contents. The research was conducted online and included the following steps: pilot study, recruitment, individualized training, sociodemographic interview, photovoice training, photo taking, focus group for contextualization, data transcription and analysis and validation of analyses by the mothers.
Content analysis revealed five categories that influenced the participation of the children: participation preferences, family relationships, access to healthcare, access to education and social isolation. Regarding participation preferences, mothers reported their children's desire to play with peers and family members and have autonomy. Mothers described the family environment as a happy, peaceful and safe place for the children. Lack of therapy was perceived to negatively impact the health of children; thus, treatments were considered essential for child development. Access to education included accessibility of remote education and a perceived lack of infrastructure and pedagogical preparation. Last, social isolation due to COVID-19 directly affected the daily lives and behaviour of the children, interrupting therapies and medical appointments.
The photos and narratives captured several aspects of the daily lives of children with CZS impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, reinforcing the importance of considering the negative effects of social isolation and offering education and social assistance to promote participation and integral health.
PATIENT/PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION: Consistent with a participatory action research framework, Mothers acted as co-researchers and participated in all stages of the research, especially in validating the data analysed by the researchers.
在巴西,超过 3500 名患有先天性 Zika 综合征(CZS)的儿童在日常生活中面临困难,而健康紧急情况(如 COVID-19 大流行)可能会使这些困难加剧。参与可以被定义为个体参与日常生活情况,而参与限制是在日常情况下可能出现的问题。
使用母亲拍摄的照片叙述来探索患有 CZS 的儿童在 COVID-19 大流行期间的日常生活,并讨论改善参与结果的可能策略。
在这项参与式行动研究中,七位年轻的巴西母亲作为共同研究者使用照片声音来描述她们患有 CZS(2 至 5 岁)的孩子的经历。此外,母亲们还对内容进行了验证。该研究在线进行,包括以下步骤:试点研究、招募、个性化培训、社会人口学访谈、照片声音培训、拍照、聚焦小组进行背景化、转录和分析数据以及由母亲验证分析。
内容分析揭示了五个影响儿童参与的类别:参与偏好、家庭关系、获得医疗保健、获得教育和社会隔离。关于参与偏好,母亲们报告说她们的孩子渴望与同伴和家人一起玩耍并拥有自主权。母亲们将家庭环境描述为孩子快乐、和平且安全的地方。缺乏治疗被认为会对孩子的健康产生负面影响,因此,治疗被认为是儿童发展的关键。获得教育包括远程教育的可及性以及基础设施和教学准备的缺乏。最后,由于 COVID-19 导致的社会隔离直接影响了患有 CZS 的儿童的日常生活和行为,中断了治疗和医疗预约。
照片和叙述捕捉到了 COVID-19 大流行影响下患有 CZS 的儿童日常生活的几个方面,强调了考虑社会隔离的负面影响以及提供教育和社会援助以促进参与和整体健康的重要性。
患者/公众贡献:符合参与式行动研究框架,母亲们作为共同研究者参与了研究的所有阶段,特别是在验证研究人员分析的数据方面。