Department of Quality of Care and Health Economics, Centre for Nutrition, Prevention and Health Services, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), 3721, MA, Bilthoven, the Netherlands.
Department of Public Health and Primary Care/ Health Campus The Hague, Leiden University Medical Centre, 2511, DP, The Hague, the Netherlands.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Aug 30;23(1):926. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-09873-y.
In 2018, the Dutch government initiated the Solid Start program to provide each child the best start in life. The program focuses on the crucial first thousand days of life, which span from preconception to a child's second birthday, and has a specific focus towards (future) parents and young children in vulnerable situations. A key program element is improving collaboration between the medical and social sector by creating Solid Start coalitions. This study aimed to describe the implementation of the Dutch Solid Start program, in order to learn for future practice and policy. Specifically, this paper describes to what extent Solid Start is implemented within municipalities and outlines stakeholders' experiences with the implementation of Solid Start and the associated cross-sectoral collaboration.
Quantitative and qualitative data were collected from 2019 until 2021. Questionnaires were sent to all 352 Dutch municipalities and analyzed using descriptive statistics. Qualitative data were obtained through focus group discussions(n = 6) and semi-structured interviews(n = 19) with representatives of care and support organizations, knowledge institutes and professional associations, Solid Start project leaders, advisors, municipal officials, researchers, clients and experts-by-experience. Qualitative data were analyzed using the Rainbow Model of Integrated Care.
Findings indicated progress in the development of Solid Start coalitions(n = 40 in 2019, n = 140 in 2021), and an increase in cross-sectoral collaboration. According to the stakeholders, initiating Solid Start increased the sense of urgency concerning the importance of the first thousand days and stimulated professionals from various backgrounds to get to know each other, resulting in more collaborative agreements on cross-sectoral care provision. Important elements mentioned for effective collaboration within coalitions were an active coordinator as driving force, and a shared societal goal. However, stakeholders experienced that Solid Start is not yet fully incorporated into all professionals' everyday practice. Most common barriers for collaboration related to systemic integration at macro-level, including limited resources and collaboration-inhibiting regulations. Stakeholders emphasized the importance of ensuring Solid Start and mentioned various needs, including sustainable funding, supportive regulations, responsiveness to stakeholders' needs, ongoing knowledge development, and client involvement.
Solid Start, as a national program with strong local focus, has led to various incremental changes that supported cross-sectoral collaboration to improve care during the first thousand days, without major transformations of systemic structures. However, to ensure the program's sustainability, needs such as sustainable funding should be addressed.
2018 年,荷兰政府启动了“坚实开端”计划,旨在为每个孩子提供最佳的人生起点。该计划侧重于生命最初的一千天,涵盖了从受孕前到孩子两岁生日期间,并特别关注处于弱势处境的(未来)父母和幼儿。该计划的一个关键内容是通过创建“坚实开端”联盟来改善医疗和社会部门之间的合作。本研究旨在描述荷兰“坚实开端”计划的实施情况,以便为未来的实践和政策提供参考。具体而言,本文描述了“坚实开端”在各市政府内部的实施程度,并概述了利益相关者对“坚实开端”的实施以及相关跨部门合作的经验。
从 2019 年到 2021 年,收集了定量和定性数据。向所有 352 个荷兰市政府发送了问卷,并使用描述性统计进行了分析。通过与护理和支持组织、知识机构和专业协会、“坚实开端”项目负责人、顾问、市政府官员、研究人员、客户和经验丰富的专家代表的焦点小组讨论(n=6)和半结构化访谈(n=19)获得了定性数据。使用彩虹模式的综合护理方法对定性数据进行了分析。
研究结果表明,“坚实开端”联盟的发展取得了进展(2019 年有 40 个,2021 年有 140 个),跨部门合作有所增加。根据利益相关者的说法,启动“坚实开端”计划增加了对最初一千天重要性的紧迫感,并促使来自不同背景的专业人员相互了解,从而在跨部门提供护理方面达成了更多的合作协议。联盟内有效合作的重要因素包括积极的协调员作为驱动力,以及共同的社会目标。然而,利益相关者表示,“坚实开端”计划尚未完全融入所有专业人员的日常实践中。合作的最常见障碍与宏观层面的系统整合有关,包括资源有限和抑制合作的法规。利益相关者强调了确保“坚实开端”计划的重要性,并提到了各种需求,包括可持续的资金、支持性的法规、对利益相关者需求的响应、持续的知识发展以及客户参与。
作为一个具有强烈地方重点的国家计划,“坚实开端”计划已经带来了各种渐进式的变革,支持了跨部门合作,以改善最初一千天的护理,但没有对系统结构进行重大转变。然而,为了确保该计划的可持续性,需要解决可持续资金等问题。