Bakkum Lianne, Schuengel Carlo, Foster Sarah L, Fearon R M Pasco, Duschinsky Robbie
University of Cambridge, UK; Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Hist Human Sci. 2023 Feb 8;36(3-4):133-157. doi: 10.1177/09526951221143645. eCollection 2023 Jul-Oct.
This article examines how 'trauma' has been conceptualised in the unresolved state of mind classification in the Adult Attachment Interview, introduced by Main and Hesse in 1990. The unresolved state of mind construct has been influential for three decades of research in developmental psychology. However, not much is known about how this measure of unresolved trauma was developed, and how it relates to other conceptualisations of trauma. We draw on previously unavailable manuscripts from Main and Hesse's personal archive, including various editions of unpublished coding manuals, and on Main-Bowlby correspondence from the John Bowlby Archive at the Wellcome Trust in London. This article traces the emergence of the unresolved state of mind classification, and examines the assumptions about trauma embedded in the construct. These assumptions are situated both in the immediate context of the work of Main and Hesse and in terms of wider discourses about trauma in the period. Our analysis considers how a particular form of trauma discourse entered into attachment research, and in doing so partly lost contact with wider disciplinary study of trauma.
本文探讨了“创伤”在成人依恋访谈中未解决的心理状态分类里是如何被概念化的,该分类由梅因和黑塞于1990年引入。未解决的心理状态结构在发展心理学三十年的研究中颇具影响力。然而,对于这种未解决创伤的测量方法是如何发展而来的,以及它与其他创伤概念化方式有何关联,我们所知甚少。我们借鉴了梅因和黑塞个人档案中此前未公开的手稿,包括未出版的编码手册的多个版本,以及伦敦惠康信托基金会约翰·鲍尔比档案中的梅因 - 鲍尔比通信。本文追溯了未解决的心理状态分类的出现,并审视了该结构中所蕴含的关于创伤的假设。这些假设既存在于梅因和黑塞工作的直接背景中,也体现在当时关于创伤的更广泛论述中。我们的分析思考了一种特定形式的创伤话语是如何进入依恋研究的,以及在此过程中它如何在一定程度上与创伤的更广泛学科研究失去了联系。