Department of Nutrition, Faculty of Medicine, Université de Montréal, Montréal, Quebec, Canada.
Centre de recherche en santé publique, Université de Montréal, Montréal, Quebec, Canada.
Health Promot Chronic Dis Prev Can. 2023 Dec;43(12):485-498. doi: 10.24095/hpcdp.43.12.01.
We analyzed the bio-food industry's corporate political activity (CPA) during the revisions of Canada's food guide between 2016 and 2019.
We undertook a content analysis of the websites of 11 bio-food industry organizations and of the briefs that 10 of them submitted to the Canadian House of Commons Standing Committee on Health, as part of this Committee's review of the food guide. Data were classified according to an existing conceptual framework.
We identified 366 examples of CPA used by the bio-food industry during and immediately after the development of the food guide. Most of the industry actors opposed the guide's recommendations. The most common CPA strategies were information management (n = 197), used to create and disseminate information in industry's favour, and discursive strategies (n = 108), used to defend food products and promote the industry's position regarding the food guide. Influencing public policy (n = 40), by gaining indirect access to policy makers (e.g. through lobbying) and becoming active in government decision-making, as well as coalition management (n = 21), by establishing relationships with opinion leaders and health organizations, were also common strategies.
Bio-food industry actors used many different CPA strategies during the revisions of the food guide. It is important to continue to document the bio-food industry's CPA to understand whether and how this is shaping public policy development in Canada and elsewhere.
我们分析了 2016 年至 2019 年加拿大食品指南修订期间生物食品行业的企业政治活动(CPA)。
我们对 11 个生物食品行业组织的网站以及其中 10 个组织向加拿大下议院健康常设委员会提交的简报进行了内容分析,作为该委员会对食品指南进行审查的一部分。数据是根据现有的概念框架进行分类的。
我们在食品指南制定期间和之后立即发现了生物食品行业进行的 366 次企业政治活动。大多数行业参与者反对指南的建议。最常见的企业政治活动策略是信息管理(n = 197),用于创建和传播有利于行业的信息,以及话语策略(n = 108),用于捍卫食品产品并宣传行业对食品指南的立场。影响公共政策(n = 40),通过间接获得决策者的机会(例如通过游说)并参与政府决策制定,以及联盟管理(n = 21),通过与意见领袖和健康组织建立关系,也是常见的策略。
生物食品行业参与者在食品指南修订期间使用了许多不同的企业政治活动策略。继续记录生物食品行业的企业政治活动以了解其是否以及如何在加拿大和其他地方影响公共政策的制定非常重要。