Farkas L G, Kolar J C, Munro I R
Aesthetic Plast Surg. 1986;10(4):191-223. doi: 10.1007/BF01575292.
The noses of 34 attractive young North American Caucasian women were analyzed quantitatively, based on 19 nasal measurements (6 single and 7 paired linear measurements, 3 angles, and 3 inclinations) and 15 craniofacial measurements (10 linear measurements and 5 inclinations) taken directly from the face of the women. The relationship between the nasal measurements was studied in 16 proportion indices and the relationship between the nasal and the other craniofacial measurements in 13 interareal indices. The findings were also compared with those in 21 women with below-average faces. Two types of facial harmony disruption were identified: disharmony, a normal index with a visually apparent failure of proportionality, and disproportion, an index value outside of the normal range. The percentage of disharmonies and disproportions was significantly higher in the group of 21 women with below-average faces. The study revealed a wide variety of "ideal" noses. Only a small portion of the measurements (12%) and proportion indices (7%) were at the mean value. At least two-thirds of the interareal proportion indices were located in the mean +/- 1 standard deviation portion of the normal range. Only about one-fifth of the interareal indices were disharmonious and 2.8% disproportionate. The disproportions were more areal in the attractive faces and more interareal in the below-average faces. The greatest disproportion in the attractive face was the moderately short columella in relation to the tip protrusion and in the below-average face the long nasal bridge related to the upper-lip height. Disproportions were associated with combinations of normal and abnormal measurements, or with two normal measurements of unequal quality, which resulted in a slightly smaller disfigurement. Analysis of ethnic and racial differences showed the soft nose as the main feature of the most characteristic differences. The study revealed that the key to restoration of facial harmony is the renewal of the uniformity of proportion index qualities by elimination disharmonies and/or disproportionate relationships.
对34名年轻迷人的北美白种女性的鼻子进行了定量分析,分析基于19项鼻部测量数据(6项单一和7项成对线性测量、3个角度和3个倾斜度)以及15项颅面部测量数据(10项线性测量和5个倾斜度),这些数据直接取自这些女性的面部。研究了16个比例指数中鼻部测量数据之间的关系,以及13个区域间指数中鼻部与其他颅面部测量数据之间的关系。研究结果还与21名面部普通的女性进行了比较。识别出了两种面部和谐破坏类型:不协调,即正常指数但视觉上比例明显失调;不成比例,即指数值超出正常范围。在21名面部普通的女性组中,不协调和不成比例的百分比显著更高。该研究揭示了各种各样的“理想”鼻子。只有一小部分测量数据(12%)和比例指数(7%)处于平均值。至少三分之二的区域间比例指数位于正常范围的平均值±1个标准差区间内。只有约五分之一的区域间指数不协调,2.8%不成比例。不成比例在迷人面部中更多是区域内的,而在面部普通的人中更多是区域间的。迷人面部中最大的不成比例是相对于鼻尖突出而言鼻小柱适度短小,而面部普通的人中最大的不成比例是鼻梁长度相对于上唇高度过长。不成比例与正常和异常测量数据的组合相关,或者与两个质量不等的正常测量数据相关,这导致了轻微较小的面容缺陷。种族差异分析表明,柔和的鼻子是最具特征性差异的主要特征。该研究表明,恢复面部和谐的关键是通过消除不协调和/或不成比例的关系来恢复比例指数质量上的一致性。