Laboratory of Functional Neuroscience, Pablo de Olavide University, 41013 Seville, Spain.
CIBERNED, Centro de Investigación Biomédica en Red de Enfermedades Neurodegenerativas, Instituto de Salud Carlos III, 28029 Madrid, Spain.
Cells. 2024 Jan 2;13(1):95. doi: 10.3390/cells13010095.
Salivary extracellular vesicles (EVs) represent an attractive source of biomarkers due to the accessibility of saliva and its non-invasive sampling methods. However, the lack of comparative studies assessing the efficacy of different EV isolation techniques hampers the use of salivary EVs in clinical settings. Moreover, the effects of age on salivary EVs are largely unknown, hindering the identification of salivary EV-associated biomarkers across the lifespan. To address these questions, we compared salivary EV concentration, size mode, protein concentration, and purity using eight EV isolation techniques before and after magnetic bead immunocapture with antibodies against CD9, CD63, and CD81. The effects of age on salivary EVs obtained with each isolation technique were further investigated. Results showed higher expression of CD63 on isolated salivary EVs compared to the expression of CD81 and flotillin-1. Overall, magnetic bead immunocapture was more efficient in recovering salivary EVs with Norgen's Saliva Exosome Purification Kit and ExoQuick-TC ULTRA at the cost of EV yield. Regardless of age, Invitrogen Total Exosome Isolation Solution showed the highest level of protein concentration, whereas Izon qEVOriginal-70nm columns revealed the highest purity. This study provides the first comprehensive comparison of salivary EVs in younger and older adults using different EV isolation techniques, which represents a step forward for assessing salivary EVs as a source of potential biomarkers of tissue-specific diseases throughout the life cycle.
唾液细胞外囊泡(EVs)是一种有吸引力的生物标志物来源,因为唾液易于获取且可采用非侵入性采样方法。然而,缺乏评估不同 EV 分离技术效果的比较研究,限制了唾液 EV 在临床环境中的应用。此外,年龄对唾液 EV 的影响在很大程度上尚未可知,这阻碍了在整个生命周期中识别与唾液 EV 相关的生物标志物。为了解决这些问题,我们在使用针对 CD9、CD63 和 CD81 的抗体进行磁珠免疫捕获前后,使用 8 种 EV 分离技术比较了唾液 EV 的浓度、大小模式、蛋白浓度和纯度。我们还进一步研究了每种分离技术获得的唾液 EV 随年龄的变化。结果表明,与 flotillin-1 相比,分离的唾液 EV 上 CD63 的表达更高。总的来说,磁珠免疫捕获法在使用 Norgen 的唾液外泌体纯化试剂盒和 ExoQuick-TC ULTRA 时,能够更有效地回收唾液 EV,但这会降低 EV 的产量。无论年龄大小,Invitrogen 总外泌体分离溶液显示出最高的蛋白浓度水平,而 Izon qEVOriginal-70nm 柱则显示出最高的纯度。本研究首次使用不同的 EV 分离技术全面比较了年轻和老年成年人的唾液 EV,这为评估唾液 EV 作为组织特异性疾病潜在生物标志物的来源提供了新的思路。