Department of Emergency Medicine, Taichung Veterans General Hospital, Taichung, Taiwan.
Division of Clinical Training, Department of Medical Education, Taichung Veterans General Hospital, Taichung, Taiwan.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Mar 23;24(1):333. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05294-5.
To evaluate the process and the comprehensiveness of advance care planning (ACP), we designed a national ACP-OSCE (Objective Structured Clinical Examination) program.
The program was designed as a 40-minute OSCE test. Participants were categorized as different ACP team members to illustrate realistic scenarios. Preceptors were asked to observe ACP professionals' actions, responses, and communication skills during ACP with standardized patients (SP) through a one-way mirror. Participants' communication skills, medical expertise, legal knowledge, empathetic response and problem-solving skills of ACP were also self-evaluated before and after OSCE. Thematic analysis was used for qualitative analysis.
In Nov 2019, a total of 18 ACP teams with 38 ACP professionals completed the ACP-OSCE program, including 15 physicians, 15 nurses, 5 social workers, and 3 psychologists. After the ACP-OSCE program, the average score of communication skills, medical expertise, legal knowledge, empathetic response, ACP problem-solving all increased. Nurses felt improved in medical expertise, legal knowledge, and problem-solving skills, psychologists and social workers felt improved in legal knowledge, while physicians felt no improved in all domain, statistically. Thematic analysis showed professional skills, doctoral-patient communication, benefit and difficulties of ACP were the topics which participants care about. Meanwhile, most participants agreed that ACP-OSCE program is an appropriate educational tool.
This is the first national ACP-OSCE program in Asia. We believe that this ACP-OSCE program could be applied in other countries to improve the ACP process and quality.
为了评估预先医疗照护计划(ACP)的流程和全面性,我们设计了一个全国性的 ACP-OSCE(客观结构化临床考试)项目。
该项目设计为 40 分钟的 OSCE 测试。参与者被分为不同的 ACP 团队成员,以说明现实场景。督导员被要求通过单向镜观察 ACP 专业人员与标准化患者(SP)进行 ACP 时的行为、反应和沟通技巧。参与者在 OSCE 前后还对自己的沟通技巧、医学专业知识、法律知识、同理心反应和 ACP 问题解决能力进行了自我评估。采用主题分析法进行定性分析。
2019 年 11 月,共有 18 个 ACP 团队的 38 名 ACP 专业人员完成了 ACP-OSCE 项目,包括 15 名医生、15 名护士、5 名社工和 3 名心理学家。在 ACP-OSCE 项目之后,沟通技巧、医学专业知识、法律知识、同理心反应和 ACP 问题解决能力的平均得分都有所提高。护士在医学专业知识、法律知识和问题解决能力方面感觉有所提高,心理学家和社工在法律知识方面感觉有所提高,而医生在所有领域都感觉没有提高,这在统计学上具有显著差异。主题分析显示,专业技能、医患沟通、ACP 的益处和困难是参与者关心的话题。同时,大多数参与者认为 ACP-OSCE 项目是一种合适的教育工具。
这是亚洲第一个全国性的 ACP-OSCE 项目。我们相信,这个 ACP-OSCE 项目可以在其他国家应用,以提高 ACP 的流程和质量。