School of Nursing, University of Tasmania, Newnham Campus, Newnham Drive, Newnham, Launceston, Tasmania 7248, Australia.
School of Nursing, University of Tasmania, Domain Campus, 71 Brooker Avenue, Glebe, Hobart, Tasmania 7001, Australia.
Health Educ Res. 2024 Jul 18;39(4):351-374. doi: 10.1093/her/cyae012.
Schools and school teachers often focus on content aimed at delaying sexual debut and preventing teenage pregnancy, and address the impacts of risky behaviours on infant health. Infant simulators are increasingly used in health education courses. However, it is unclear how effective this education is. In this review, we examined the evidence for the effectiveness and use of pregnancy/parenting education programmes for school-aged students using infant simulators. Infant simulators are lifelike replicas of human newborn babies that have electronic capacity to mimic a range of infant behaviours. These may include feeding, comfort needs and nappy changing. Responses to these replicated behaviours may be recorded to provide feedback of the adequacy of the response for educational purposes and provide feedback to prospective parents and caregivers. This review followed the guidelines for conducting a scoping review developed by Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI). After following the process as recommended by the JBI, 32 eligible articles were selected for inclusion. Eight themes emerged from the analysis and it was found that the use of infant simulators in terms of effectiveness was not conclusive. This may be due to lack of longitudinal studies examining the impact of the education provided. Furthermore, the literature did not address innovations of infant simulators that replicate infants with particular characteristics, those with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, shaken baby syndrome or challenges from parental substance use. Further research is required to determine the long-term impact of using infant simulators on reducing risky behaviours. Given these challenges, it is important to support initiatives for sex, pregnancy and parenting education among all students.
学校和教师通常专注于旨在延迟性初潮和预防青少年怀孕的内容,并解决危险行为对婴儿健康的影响。婴儿模拟器越来越多地用于健康教育课程。然而,目前尚不清楚这种教育的效果如何。在本次综述中,我们使用婴儿模拟器检查了针对学龄学生的怀孕/育儿教育计划的有效性和使用情况的证据。婴儿模拟器是逼真的人类新生儿复制品,具有模拟一系列婴儿行为的电子能力。这些行为可能包括喂养、舒适需求和更换尿布。可以记录对这些复制行为的反应,以便为教育目的提供对反应充分性的反馈,并为未来的父母和照顾者提供反馈。本次综述遵循了由 Joanna Briggs 研究所 (JBI) 制定的进行范围综述的指南。按照 JBI 推荐的流程进行操作后,选择了 32 篇符合条件的文章进行纳入。从分析中出现了 8 个主题,发现使用婴儿模拟器在有效性方面没有定论。这可能是由于缺乏纵向研究来检验所提供教育的影响。此外,文献并未涉及复制具有特定特征的婴儿、胎儿酒精谱系障碍、摇晃婴儿综合征或父母物质使用挑战的婴儿模拟器的创新。需要进一步研究以确定使用婴儿模拟器减少危险行为的长期影响。鉴于这些挑战,重要的是要支持所有学生的性、怀孕和育儿教育计划。