School of Nursing, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Faculty of Management, The University of British Columbia, Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada.
Am J Mens Health. 2024 Mar-Apr;18(2):15579883241247173. doi: 10.1177/15579883241247173.
Men historically consume more meat than women, show fewer intentions to reduce meat consumption, and are underrepresented among vegans and vegetarians. Eating meat strongly aligns with normative masculinities, decisively affirming that "real men" eat meat and subordinating men who choose to be veg* (vegan or vegetarian). The emergence of meat alternatives and increasing environmental concerns may contest these long-standing masculine norms and hierarchies. The current scoping review addresses the research question Using keywords derived from two key concepts, "men" and "meat," 39 articles were selected and analyzed to inductively derive three thematic findings; (a) Meat as Masculine, (b) Vegn Men as Othered, and (c) Vegnism as Contemporary Masculinity. included how men's gendered identities, defenses, and physicalities were entwined with meat consumption. explored the social and cultural challenges faced by men who adopt meatless diets, including perceptions of emasculation. was claimed by men who eschewed meat in their diets and advocated for veg*nism as legitimate masculine capital through linkages to physical strength, rationality, self-determination, courage, and discipline. In light of the growing concern about the ecological impact of meat production and the adverse health outcomes associated with its excessive consumption, this review summarizes empirical connections between masculinities and the consumption of meat to consider directions for future men's health promotion research, policy, and practice.
男性历来比女性摄入更多的肉类,减少肉类摄入的意愿也较低,在纯素食者和素食者中代表性不足。吃肉强烈符合规范的男性气质,明确肯定“真正的男人”吃肉,并将选择吃素的男性置于次要地位(纯素食者或素食者)。肉类替代品的出现和日益增长的环境问题可能会对这些长期存在的男性规范和等级制度提出挑战。目前的范围综述旨在回答以下研究问题:使用两个关键概念“男性”和“肉类”衍生的关键词,选择并分析了 39 篇文章,以归纳出三个主题发现;(a)肉类与男性气质,(b)素食男性被边缘化,以及(c)素食主义作为当代男性气质。探讨了男性的性别认同、防御机制和肉体如何与肉类消费交织在一起。探讨了男性采用无肉饮食所面临的社会和文化挑战,包括被去势化的看法。声称通过将与体力、理性、自主性、勇气和纪律联系起来,避免饮食中的肉类并倡导素食主义作为合法的男性资本,这种做法被拒绝肉类的男性所接受。鉴于人们对肉类生产对生态的影响以及其过度消费对健康的不利影响日益关注,本综述总结了男性气质与肉类消费之间的实证联系,以考虑未来男性健康促进研究、政策和实践的方向。