Bergien Sofie Olsgaard, Skovgaard Lasse, Steenberg Josephine Lyngh, Kristiansen Maria
The Danish Multiple Sclerosis Society, Poul Bundgaards Vej 1, Valby, 2500, Denmark.
Department of Public Health & Center for Healthy Aging, University of Copenhagen, Fredericiagade 18, Copenhagen K, 1310, Denmark.
Res Involv Engagem. 2024 Jul 31;10(1):78. doi: 10.1186/s40900-024-00614-x.
Participatory research has gained traction as an approach to unlock perspectives when creating scientific knowledge and to facilitate societal changes. By conducting research with people, participatory research strives to engage individuals' perspectives in designing, conducting, and disseminating the research. Nevertheless, few studies have unpacked how understandings of the studied phenomenon are shaped among diverse research partners and, concurrently, how different perspectives are combined. Nested within an overall participatory mixed methods study on aging with multiple sclerosis (MS), this qualitative study explores how understandings of aging with MS are shaped in encounters between university researchers, older adults with MS, and employees in a patient association.
The study was collaboratively conducted in Denmark by three research partners: a group of older adults with MS, employees in a patient association, and university researchers. Data on how different understandings of aging with MS were represented and shaped during the three-year research process was generated through field notes, meeting minutes, focus group interviews, and individual interviews. The collected data was analyzed through a thematic network analysis.
The study demonstrates how different understandings of aging with MS were represented among the research partners when the research was initiated. These understandings were shaped prior to -and, therefore, outside-the research setting, drawing from the research participants' lived experiences, professional backgrounds, and organizational cultures or situated in larger societal narratives. Through a process centered on reflexivity among the engaged research partners, the understandings of what it means to age with MS was shaped and re-shaped and eventually merged into a more dynamic understanding of later life with MS where different perspectives could co-exist.
The findings demonstrate that research partners, including older adults with MS and employees from a patient association, brought diverse understandings to the study. Reflexive practices enabled these perspectives to co-exist, enhancing engagement and transparency, and fostering a dynamic understanding of later life with MS. This highlights the value of reflexivity in evolving complex understandings within participatory research.
参与式研究作为一种在创造科学知识时开启不同视角并推动社会变革的方法,已越来越受到关注。通过与人们一起开展研究,参与式研究力求让个人观点参与到研究的设计、实施和传播过程中。然而,很少有研究剖析在不同的研究伙伴中,对所研究现象的理解是如何形成的,以及与此同时,不同观点是如何融合的。本定性研究嵌套于一项关于多发性硬化症(MS)患者老龄化的整体参与式混合方法研究中,探讨了大学研究人员、患有MS的老年人以及患者协会员工之间的交流互动如何塑造了对MS患者老龄化的理解。
该研究由丹麦的三个研究伙伴合作开展:一组患有MS的老年人、患者协会员工以及大学研究人员。通过实地记录、会议纪要、焦点小组访谈和个人访谈,收集了在为期三年的研究过程中,对MS患者老龄化的不同理解是如何呈现和形成的数据。通过主题网络分析法对收集到的数据进行了分析。
该研究展示了在研究启动时,研究伙伴们对MS患者老龄化有着不同的理解。这些理解在研究开展之前,也就是在研究背景之外就已形成,源于研究参与者的生活经历、专业背景和组织文化,或者来自更广泛社会层面的叙述。通过一个以参与研究的伙伴之间的反思为核心的过程,对MS患者老龄化的理解不断被塑造和重塑,最终融合为一种对MS患者晚年生活更具动态性的理解,不同观点得以共存。
研究结果表明,包括患有MS的老年人和患者协会员工在内的研究伙伴为该研究带来了多样的理解。反思性实践使这些观点能够共存,增强了参与度和透明度,并促进了对MS患者晚年生活的动态理解。这凸显了反思性在参与式研究中深化复杂理解方面的价值。