Kotsia Alkisti, Pechlivanidou Evmorfia, Kalpourtzi Natasa, Vourli Georgia, Papaevangelou Vana, Touloumi Giota, Benetou Vasiliki
Department of Hygiene, Epidemiology and Medical Statistics, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine, Athens, GRC.
Third Department of Pediatrics, Attikon University Hospital, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens School of Medicine, Athens, GRC.
Cureus. 2024 Jul 15;16(7):e64588. doi: 10.7759/cureus.64588. eCollection 2024 Jul.
Vaccinations have reduced illnesses and mortality rates globally, yet negative attitudes and uncertainty about them hinder their acceptability and efficacy. The study aims to document Greek parents' immunization perceptions and risk factors.
Spanning 2014-2017, 447 parents (68% mothers) who participated in the Greek Health Examination Survey EMENO (National Survey of Morbidity and Risk Factors) completed an interview-delivered questionnaire. Attitudes were categorized into three groups: absolutely positive, positive, and negative. Absolutely positive attitudes included positive responses to all five statements in favor of vaccination and negative responses to the two statements against vaccination. Negative attitudes included positive responses to either one or both statements against vaccination and negative responses to all five statements in favor of vaccination.. All other participants were categorized as having a positive attitude. Skepticism towards vaccinations was classified into skeptical and non-skeptical groups based on responses to five statements implying uncertainty or skepticism. Participants were considered skeptical if they provided positive responses to at least three of these statements, and non-skeptical if they had none or up to two positive responses. The statistical analysis accounted for the study design whereas inverse probability weighting was used to adjust for non-response and multiple imputations were employed to impute missing values. The components of parental attitude and vaccine skepticism were identified using weighted multinomial logistic regression and logistic regression, respectively.
In total, 16.6% were classified as having absolutely positive attitudes towards vaccinations whereas 42.1% were skeptical of vaccines. Of all participants, 96.0% agreed that vaccinations are essential for their child's well-being and adhere to scientific recommendations. However, concerns were also mentioned, with 26.2% worrying about potential adverse effects, and 21.6% believing it is better to acquire immunity through illness rather than vaccination. Positive participants, compared to absolutely positive ones, were more likely to be of Greek origin (adjusted relative rate ratio (aRRR): 3.35; 95% CI: 1.53-7.30) and living in semi-urban areas (aRRR: 4.84; 95% CI: 1.77-13.29). Negative participants, in contrast, were more likely to have higher education (aRRR: 2.98; 95% CI: 1.05-8.44) but also to live in semi-urban areas (aRRR: 6.43; 95% CI: 1.69-24.56). Furthermore, parents of Greek origin had significantly higher odds of being skeptical towards vaccination (adjusted Odds Ratio (aOR): 2.86; 95% CI: 1.36-5.98), while married or cohabiting parents had lower odds of being skeptical compared to single parents (aOR: 0.60; 95% CI: 0.35-1.06).
While parents in this study recognize the importance of childhood immunizations, there is a widespread presence of negative attitudes and skepticism that can have a detrimental impact on vaccination rates.
疫苗接种已在全球范围内降低了疾病发病率和死亡率,但人们对疫苗的负面态度和不确定性阻碍了其可接受性和有效性。本研究旨在记录希腊父母对免疫接种的看法及风险因素。
在2014年至2017年期间,447名参与希腊健康检查调查EMENO(全国发病率和风险因素调查)的父母(68%为母亲)完成了一份通过访谈发放的问卷。态度被分为三组:绝对积极、积极和消极。绝对积极态度包括对所有五条支持疫苗接种的陈述都给出肯定回答,以及对两条反对疫苗接种的陈述都给出否定回答。消极态度包括对一条或两条反对疫苗接种的陈述给出肯定回答,以及对所有五条支持疫苗接种的陈述都给出否定回答。所有其他参与者被归类为持积极态度。根据对五条暗示不确定性或怀疑态度的陈述的回答,对疫苗接种的怀疑被分为怀疑和不怀疑两组。如果参与者对这些陈述中至少三条给出肯定回答,则被视为怀疑;如果没有或只有两条以下肯定回答,则被视为不怀疑。统计分析考虑了研究设计,采用逆概率加权法对无应答情况进行调整,并采用多重填补法填补缺失值。分别使用加权多项逻辑回归和逻辑回归来确定父母态度和疫苗怀疑的组成部分。
总体而言,16.6%的人被归类为对疫苗接种持绝对积极态度,而42.1%的人对疫苗持怀疑态度。在所有参与者中,96.0%的人同意疫苗接种对孩子的健康至关重要,并遵循科学建议。然而,也有人提到了担忧,26.2%的人担心潜在的不良反应,21.6%的人认为通过患病获得免疫力比接种疫苗更好。与绝对积极的参与者相比,持积极态度的参与者更有可能是希腊裔(调整后的相对率比(aRRR):3.35;95%置信区间:1.53 - 7.30),且居住在半城市地区(aRRR:4.84;95%置信区间:1.77 - 13.29)。相比之下,持消极态度的参与者更有可能受过高等教育(aRRR:2.98;95%置信区间:1.05 - 8.44),但也居住在半城市地区(aRRR:6.43;95%置信区间:1.69 - 24.56)。此外,希腊裔父母对疫苗接种持怀疑态度的几率显著更高(调整后的优势比(aOR):2.86;95%置信区间:1.36 - 5.98),而与单亲父母相比,已婚或同居父母持怀疑态度的几率较低(aOR:0.60;95%置信区间:0.35 - 1.06)。
虽然本研究中的父母认识到儿童免疫接种的重要性,但负面态度和怀疑情绪普遍存在,这可能会对疫苗接种率产生不利影响。