Shevlin Mark, Hyland Philip, Cloitre Marylène, Brewin Chris, Martsenkovskyi Dmytro, Ben-Ezra Menachem, Bondjers Kristina, Karatzias Thanos, Duffy Michael, Redican Enya
School of Psychology, Ulster University, Coleraine, Northern Ireland.
Department of Psychology, Maynooth University, Kildare, Ireland.
J Trauma Stress. 2025 Feb;38(1):174-180. doi: 10.1002/jts.23100. Epub 2024 Aug 19.
Psychological assessment is commonly conducted using either self-report measures or clinical interviews; the former are quick and easy to administer, and the latter are more time-consuming and require training. Self-report measures have been criticized for producing higher estimates of symptom and disorder presence relative to clinical interviews, with the assumption being that self-report measures are prone to Type 1 error. Here, we introduce the use of "clinical checks" within an existing self-report measure. These are brief supplementary questions intended to clarify and confirm initial responses, similar to what occurs in a clinical interview. Clinical checks were developed for the items of the International Grief Questionnaire (IGQ), a self-report measure of ICD-11 prolonged grief disorder (PGD). Data were collected as part of a community survey of mental health in Ukraine. Individual symptom endorsements for the IGQ significantly decreased with the use of clinical checks, and the percentage of the sample that met the ICD-11 diagnostic requirements for PGD fell from 13.6% to 10.2%, representing a 24.8% reduction in cases. The value and potential broader application of clinical checks are discussed.
心理评估通常采用自我报告测量法或临床访谈法进行;前者实施起来快速简便,而后者则较为耗时且需要培训。自我报告测量法因相对于临床访谈而言对症状和障碍存在情况的估计值更高而受到批评,人们认为自我报告测量法容易出现I类错误。在此,我们介绍在现有的自我报告测量法中使用“临床核查”。这些是简短的补充问题,旨在澄清和确认初始回答,类似于临床访谈中的情况。临床核查是针对国际哀伤问卷(IGQ)的项目开发的,IGQ是一种对国际疾病分类第11版(ICD - 11)中持续性哀伤障碍(PGD)的自我报告测量工具。数据是作为乌克兰心理健康社区调查的一部分收集的。使用临床核查后,IGQ的个体症状认可显著减少,符合ICD - 11中PGD诊断要求的样本百分比从13.6%降至10.2%,病例数减少了24.8%。本文讨论了临床核查的价值及其更广泛应用的潜力。