Raglio Alfredo, Figini Camilla, Bencivenni Alice, Grossi Federica, Boschetti Federica, Manera Marina Rita
Music Therapy Research Laboratory, Istituti Clinici Scientifici Maugeri IRCCS, Via Maugeri, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Independent Researcher, 22070 Locate Varesino, Italy.
Brain Sci. 2024 Aug 22;14(8):842. doi: 10.3390/brainsci14080842.
The use of music in cognitive interventions represents a possibility with potential worthy of further investigation in the field of aging, both in terms of prevention from dementia, in the phase of mild cognitive impairment, and in the treatment of overt dementia.
Currently, the types of music-based interventions proposed in the literature are characterized by wide heterogeneity, which is why it is necessary to clarify which interventions present more evidence of effectiveness in stimulating different cognitive domains.
The study was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines for scoping reviews. By searching two different databases, PubMed and the Web of Science, all studies evaluating the cognitive effects of music-based interventions on people at early stages of cognitive decline (MCI or mild-to-moderate dementia) were selected.
The study selection included a total of 28 studies involving n = 1612 participants (mean age ranged from 69.45 to 85.3 years old). Most of the studies analyzed agree with the observation of an improvement, or at least maintenance, of global cognitive conditions (mainly represented by the results of the MMSE test) following music-based interventions, together with a series of other positive effects on verbal fluency, memory, and executive processes.
The results of this review suggest the introduction of music-based interventions as complementary approaches to usual cognitive treatments. Also, the use of standardized and well-defined protocols, in addition to strong methodological research approaches, is suggested. Music-based interventions are recommended in the early stages of dementia, in MCI, and in a preventive sense in healthy older adults.
在认知干预中使用音乐具有一定可能性,在衰老领域,无论是在轻度认知障碍阶段预防痴呆症,还是在显性痴呆症的治疗方面,都值得进一步研究。
目前,文献中提出的基于音乐的干预类型具有很大的异质性,这就是为什么有必要明确哪些干预措施在刺激不同认知领域方面更具有效性证据。
该研究按照PRISMA范围综述指南进行。通过搜索两个不同的数据库,即PubMed和科学网,筛选出所有评估基于音乐的干预对认知衰退早期(轻度认知障碍或轻度至中度痴呆)人群认知影响的研究。
研究筛选共纳入28项研究,涉及n = 1612名参与者(平均年龄在69.45岁至85.3岁之间)。大多数分析的研究都认同基于音乐的干预后整体认知状况有所改善或至少得以维持(主要由简易精神状态检查表测试结果体现),同时对语言流畅性、记忆力和执行过程还有一系列其他积极影响。
本综述结果表明可引入基于音乐的干预作为常规认知治疗的补充方法。此外,除了采用强有力的方法学研究方法外,还建议使用标准化且定义明确的方案。建议在痴呆症早期、轻度认知障碍阶段以及对健康老年人进行预防性干预时采用基于音乐的干预措施。