Niles Charles R, Crinzi Alexander R, Bonaventura Russell, Taylor David A
Ophthalmology Associates of WNY, Williamsville, NY, United States.
Department of Ophthalmology, State University of New York at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY, United States.
Front Ophthalmol (Lausanne). 2024 Aug 16;4:1441343. doi: 10.3389/fopht.2024.1441343. eCollection 2024.
To evaluate the accuracy of the new Tono-Vera rebound tonometer (Reichert Inc, Buffalo, NY) compared to Goldmann Applanation Tonometry.
This prospective, observational, cross-sectional study was designed in accordance with ANSI Z80.10-2014 and ISO 8612-2009 guidelines for tonometer comparison. Intraocular Pressure (IOP) was measured by Goldmann Applanation and Tono-Vera on 160 eyes of 160 subjects. Corneal Astigmatism and Central Corneal Thickness were also measured. A single investigator (CN) conducted all measurements. The average of two measurements from each tonometer was used in the analysis. Bland-Altman plots, total least squares regression analysis, and simple linear regression were used to evaluate agreement between the tonometers.
Average IOP values from Goldmann Applanation and Tono-Vera were not significantly different (19.17 and 19.03 respectively, p=0.40, paired t-test). The total least squares regression analysis indicated strong agreement between the two tonometers (slope +0.97, offset +0.49 mmHg, standard deviation 2.11 mmHg). There were 2 IOP measurement pairs that exceeded the ± 5 mmHg limits of agreement required in ANSI Z80.10-2014 and ISO 8612-2009, which is within the range of acceptability specified in the standards.
We evaluated IOP measurements by Tono-Vera Rebound Tonometer vs Goldmann Applanation Tonometry for eyes with a wide range of IOP values and found no statistically significant differences in the results. Tono-Vera meets the requirements of ANSI Z80.10-2014 and ISO 8612-2009, demonstrating accuracy comparable to Goldmann tonometry.
评估新型回弹式眼压计(Tono-Vera,瑞特公司,纽约州布法罗市)与Goldmann压平眼压计相比的准确性。
本前瞻性、观察性横断面研究是根据ANSI Z80.10 - 2014和ISO 8612 - 2009眼压计比较指南设计的。对160名受试者的160只眼睛使用Goldmann压平眼压计和Tono-Vera眼压计测量眼压(IOP)。还测量了角膜散光和中央角膜厚度。由单一研究者(CN)进行所有测量。分析中使用每种眼压计两次测量的平均值。采用Bland-Altman图、总最小二乘法回归分析和简单线性回归来评估眼压计之间的一致性。
Goldmann压平眼压计和Tono-Vera眼压计的平均眼压值无显著差异(分别为19.17和19.03,p = 0.40,配对t检验)。总最小二乘法回归分析表明两种眼压计之间具有高度一致性(斜率 +0.97,偏移量 +0.49 mmHg,标准差2.11 mmHg)。有2对眼压测量值超出了ANSI Z80.10 - 2014和ISO 8612 - 2009规定的±5 mmHg一致性限度,这在标准规定的可接受范围内。
我们评估了Tono-Vera回弹式眼压计与Goldmann压平眼压计对广泛眼压值范围的眼睛进行眼压测量的情况,结果发现无统计学显著差异。Tono-Vera符合ANSI Z80.10 - 2014和ISO 8612 - 2009的要求,显示出与Goldmann眼压计相当的准确性。