Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Northwest Kidney Centers, Seattle, WA, United States.
Front Public Health. 2024 Aug 21;12:1348117. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1348117. eCollection 2024.
There is nationwide shortage of child and adolescent behavioral health providers. Lack of diversity in the mental health care profession compounds workforce capacity issues, contributing to greater disparities in treatment access and engagement for youth from historically disenfranchised communities. Strategies are needed to foster cross-sector alignment to inform policy which can improve mental health care access and reduce disparities. This current case study details a specific research-practice-policy partnership strategy, storyboarding, as a method to engage community partners in Washington State to deliberate on information drawn from research on non-specialist models of child and adolescent mental health care to support the behavioral workforce expansion.
Research evidence from a scoping literature review on non-specialist models of child and adolescent mental health care was shared via storyboards with community partners to inform policy efforts around the behavioral health workforce expansion. In Phase 1, community members with lived experience and clinical expertise contributed to the storyboard design process. In Phase 2, a broader community partner group shared their perspectives on the models of care presented in the storyboards via Qualtrics survey with open-ended questions. Listening sessions were also held with non-English speaking refugee and immigrant communities to elicit feedback on whether these models of care would meet their needs. Qualitative data was coded to explore emerging themes using a rapid deductive approach.
Community partners shared mixed responses to models of care presented from the research literature. Immigrant and refugee communities explicitly stated these existing models would not fit their context. Regarding partnership strategy success, the smaller community partner group was engaged in the storyboard design process. The broader community interacted with and provided detailed responses to the models of care presented in the storyboards. Success was also reflected in community partners' continued participation in the next stage of the project.
Findings demonstrate how storyboarding can be effectively used to translate research evidence into accessible information to promote community partner engagement and capture community voice in policy processes. More work is needed exploring how such methods can be used to increase the use of research evidence in policy and practice spaces.
全国范围内儿童和青少年行为健康提供者短缺。心理健康护理行业缺乏多样性,加剧了劳动力能力问题,导致历史上被剥夺权利的社区的青年在获得治疗方面的差距更大。需要制定战略来促进跨部门的协调一致,为政策提供信息,从而改善精神卫生保健的获取途径并减少差距。本案例研究详细介绍了一种具体的研究-实践-政策伙伴关系策略,即故事板,用于让华盛顿州的社区合作伙伴参与讨论关于非专业儿童和青少年心理健康护理模式的研究信息,以支持行为劳动力的扩大。
通过故事板向社区合作伙伴分享非专业儿童和青少年心理健康护理模式的广泛文献综述研究证据,以告知围绕行为健康劳动力扩大的政策努力。在第一阶段,有生活经验和临床专业知识的社区成员为故事板设计过程做出了贡献。在第二阶段,更广泛的社区合作伙伴群体通过带有开放式问题的 Qualtrics 调查,分享了他们对故事板中呈现的护理模式的看法。还与非英语的难民和移民社区举行了听证会,以征求他们对这些护理模式是否满足他们需求的反馈。使用快速演绎方法对定性数据进行编码,以探索新出现的主题。
社区合作伙伴对文献中的护理模式的反应喜忧参半。移民和难民社区明确表示,这些现有模式不符合他们的背景。关于伙伴关系策略的成功,较小的社区合作伙伴群体参与了故事板的设计过程。更广泛的社区与故事板中呈现的护理模式进行了互动,并提供了详细的反馈。社区合作伙伴在项目的下一阶段继续参与也反映了成功。
研究结果表明,故事板如何有效地将研究证据转化为可访问的信息,以促进社区合作伙伴的参与,并在政策过程中捕捉社区的声音。需要做更多的工作来探索如何利用这些方法来增加研究证据在政策和实践领域的使用。