Turk Julien, Odorizzi Scott, Dewhirst Sebastian, Maher Jessica, Landreville Jeffrey M
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
The Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, The Ottawa Hospital, Civic Campus, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
CJEM. 2024 Dec;26(12):890-896. doi: 10.1007/s43678-024-00781-6. Epub 2024 Sep 27.
This cohort study aimed to investigate resident physician productivity in an academic emergency department (ED) and assess the impact of longitudinal coaching relationships known as clinical coaching teams and co-learners (medical students) on resident productivity.
Data from patient visits to two academic EDs in Ottawa, Canada between April 2022 and March 2023 were analyzed. The attending physician schedule, learner arrangements, and patient ED treatment team information were collected. The presence or absence of clinical coaching teams was also recorded. Mean productivity, measured as patients per hour, was calculated for different shifts and learner arrangements. Linear regression and paired t tests were performed for analysis across ambulatory and non-ambulatory settings, with a focus on productivity differences across residents' training programs and level of training.
A total of 142,386 ED visits were included in the analysis across 8161 attending physician shifts. Resident productivity increased with each year of training, with Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada emergency medicine residents being the most productive by year 5. There was no significant difference in productivity between residents on clinical coaching team shifts compared to non-clinical coaching team shifts. Productivity decreased slightly when residents worked with medical students as co-learners. There was no significant relationship between the difference in productivity on shifts with and without a medical student and year of training.
This study is the first of its kind to describe resident physician productivity in a Canadian emergency department. The results of this study demonstrate that resident physician productivity improves with seniority, and that co-learners and clinical coaching teams do not significantly impact productivity. This information will be useful to program directors and residents to help set realistic expectations around productivity and to ED physician leads in planning service delivery for patients in the context of a training program.
本队列研究旨在调查学术性急诊科住院医师的工作效率,并评估被称为临床指导团队和共同学习者(医学生)的纵向指导关系对住院医师工作效率的影响。
分析了2022年4月至2023年3月期间加拿大渥太华两家学术性急诊科患者就诊的数据。收集了主治医师排班、学习者安排和患者急诊科治疗团队信息。还记录了临床指导团队的有无。以每小时患者数衡量的平均工作效率针对不同班次和学习者安排进行了计算。对门诊和非门诊环境进行了线性回归和配对t检验分析,重点关注不同住院医师培训项目和培训水平之间的工作效率差异。
分析纳入了8161个主治医师班次的总共142386次急诊科就诊。住院医师的工作效率随着培训年份的增加而提高,到第5年时,加拿大皇家内科医师和外科医师学院急诊医学住院医师的工作效率最高。与非临床指导团队班次相比,临床指导团队班次的住院医师工作效率没有显著差异。当住院医师与医学生作为共同学习者一起工作时,工作效率略有下降。有医学生参与和没有医学生参与的班次之间的工作效率差异与培训年份之间没有显著关系。
本研究是同类研究中首个描述加拿大急诊科住院医师工作效率的研究。本研究结果表明,住院医师的工作效率随资历提高,且共同学习者和临床指导团队对工作效率没有显著影响。这些信息将有助于项目主任和住院医师围绕工作效率设定现实期望,并有助于急诊科医师负责人在培训项目背景下为患者规划服务提供。