Marine Affairs Program, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Mi'kmaw Conservation Group, The Confederacy of Mainland Mi'kmaq, Truro, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Conserv Biol. 2024 Dec;38(6):e14396. doi: 10.1111/cobi.14396.
Social and economic position and power shape everyone, including scientists and researchers. The way researchers do conservation science and the voices centered in the process are a result of researcher upbringing, experiences, access to resources, and values and are a manifestation of positionality. Positionality is a concept that can help one think about one's position and power in one's work. Creating a successful research partnership requires careful thinking about how equity, diversity, inclusivity, and accessibility are accounted for in the research environment. We drew on our own experiences as early career, mid-career, and Indigenous researchers to explore researcher positionality and how understanding one's positionality can bring to the fore power dynamics in conservation science and research. We focused on the use of reflexive practice to recognize diverse roles and responsibilities, build strong project governance, and enrich relationships. We considered 2 large research partnerships, Apoqnmatulti'k (Mi'kmaw for we help each other) and the SakKijânginnaniattut Nunatsiavut Sivunitsangit (Inuttitut for Sustainable Nunatsiavut Futures) project, to examine moments of tension and interrogation of power and the ways in which this interrogation led to stronger relationships and better research. We advise that large transdisciplinary and cross-cultural research teams use positionality and reflexivity to explicitly make choices about power dynamics in the context of executing partnership-driven work. This can be accomplished through personal and collective interrogation of the power dynamics at play in project administration, research questions, and interpersonal relationships.
社会和经济地位与权力塑造了每个人,包括科学家和研究人员。研究人员从事保护科学的方式以及该过程中关注的声音,是研究人员成长背景、经验、资源获取、价值观的结果,也是其立场的表现。立场性是一个可以帮助人们思考自己在工作中的位置和权力的概念。创建成功的研究合作伙伴关系需要仔细考虑在研究环境中如何考虑公平性、多样性、包容性和可及性。我们借鉴了自己作为早期职业、中期职业和土著研究人员的经验,探讨了研究人员的立场性,以及了解自己的立场性如何突出保护科学和研究中的权力动态。我们重点关注使用反思性实践来认识到不同的角色和责任、建立强大的项目治理以及丰富关系。我们考虑了两个大型研究合作伙伴关系,Apoqnmatulti'k(米克马克语,意为我们互相帮助)和 SakKijânginnaniattut Nunatsiavut Sivunitsangit(因努特语,意为可持续的努纳武特未来)项目,以考察紧张时刻和对权力的质疑,以及这种质疑如何导致更强的关系和更好的研究。我们建议大型跨学科和跨文化研究团队在执行以伙伴关系为导向的工作时,使用立场性和反思性来明确选择权力动态。这可以通过对项目管理、研究问题和人际关系中发挥作用的权力动态进行个人和集体的质疑来实现。