Ferrara Pietro, Cipolla Domenico, Corsello Giovanni, Lagalla Luca M, Tantillo Matilde, Galione Giusyelisa, Martorana Chiara, Mazzone Teresa, Zona Margherita, Cammisa Ignazio
Department of Medicine and Surgery, Università Campus Bio-Medico, Rome, Italy.
Operative Research Unit of Pediatrics, Fondazione Policlinico Universitario Campus Bio-Medico, Rome, Italy.
Ital J Pediatr. 2024 Dec 5;50(1):258. doi: 10.1186/s13052-024-01825-4.
The Child Opportunity Index (COI) is a new and innovative tool designed to assess the environment in which children grow up, offering a broad evaluation of the opportunities available to them in different neighborhoods. This initiative aims to ensure improvements in children's living conditions and future health outcomes.
The study was performed in the cities of Palermo and Rome. Our Italian COI consists of three main domains: education, health and environment, and economy, each subdivided into specific indicators. We collected information, when available, useful for our indicators from institutional sites and municipal archives. Furthermore, in the city of Rome, we distributed a questionnaire through local pediatricians, collecting data in 2 randomly chosen neighborhoods with questions on children's health and quality of life, proposing an initial approach that, when implemented using data provided by the government and public and private health institutions, aims to evaluate the correlation between socio-economic opportunities and the psycho-physical health of children, as demonstrated in the literature.
As a result, many aspects, such as the rate of air pollution or the illegal occupation of houses, were not taken into consideration. We therefore consider our COI proposal only a starting model that will have to be implemented once all the necessary information has been obtained. However, what can be deduced from this first descriptive study is how the opportunities in different neighborhoods are not the same for all children. The number of educational opportunities as well as the number of environmental opportunities differs between the various districts and is not homogeneous between different cities or within the same city.
In conclusion, it is not simple to analyze in a scientific manner the child's health impact of living in different areas. The COI could be a useful and simple tool that can give us this information. Pediatricians could collaborate with institutions to implement intervention plans and to reduce existing differences, social and health inequalities. Future studies will have to implement this pilot study to create and validate an Italian model of COI to be used as a useful tool in children's assistance.
儿童机会指数(COI)是一种全新的创新性工具,旨在评估儿童成长的环境,对他们在不同社区可获得的机会进行全面评估。该倡议旨在确保改善儿童的生活条件和未来的健康状况。
该研究在巴勒莫和罗马市进行。我们的意大利儿童机会指数由三个主要领域组成:教育、健康与环境以及经济,每个领域又细分为具体指标。我们尽可能从机构网站和市政档案中收集对我们的指标有用的信息。此外,在罗马市,我们通过当地儿科医生发放问卷,在2个随机选择的社区收集有关儿童健康和生活质量的数据,提出了一种初步方法,当利用政府以及公共和私立卫生机构提供的数据实施该方法时,旨在评估社会经济机会与儿童身心健康之间的相关性,正如文献中所表明的那样。
结果,许多方面,如空气污染率或房屋非法占用情况,未被考虑在内。因此,我们认为我们提出的儿童机会指数只是一个初始模型,一旦获得所有必要信息就必须加以实施。然而,从这项首次描述性研究中可以推断出,不同社区的机会对所有儿童来说并不相同。不同城区的教育机会数量以及环境机会数量存在差异,并且在不同城市之间或同一城市内部也不均衡。
总之,以科学方式分析生活在不同地区对儿童健康的影响并非易事。儿童机会指数可能是一个有用且简单的工具,能为我们提供此类信息。儿科医生可以与各机构合作实施干预计划,以减少现有的差异、社会和健康不平等现象。未来的研究将不得不实施这项试点研究,以创建并验证一个意大利儿童机会指数模型,用作儿童援助的有用工具。