Amutah-Onukagha Ndidiamaka, Black Adriana, Harville Emily W, Gifuni-Koutsouris Jacqueline, Shah Ayesha, Hernandez Brenda, Datta Isha, Howard Sophie
Amaka Consulting and Evaluation Services, LLC, Boston, MA, USA.
Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts, Boston, MA, USA.
Matern Child Health J. 2025 Feb;29(2):164-172. doi: 10.1007/s10995-024-04034-x. Epub 2024 Dec 14.
To demonstrate the process and results of an equity analysis of a reproductive health association.
A series of quantitative surveys and qualitative interviews were conducted with employees of Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts (PPLM), assessing different aspects of equity. Amaka Consulting and Evaluation Services, LLC, an external consulting agency, analyzed the results and provided recommendations for improvements.
Between 25% and 33% of the employees identified as Black, Indigenous, and people of color (BIPOC). Staff expressed a high degree of satisfaction with the organization's alignment to its mission and commitment to equity. Turnover was higher among BIPOC employees, and employees of color were less likely to say they had confidence in senior management. Themes that arose frequently in surveys included the need for increased communication around equity action steps, greater accountability, and work environment issues. Qualitative interviews indicated acknowledgment of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) efforts but feeling that they were not as legitimate as they could be and vocalized a need for more equitable hiring. Recommendations for improvements included tracking feedback around social movements; conducting equity impact assessments; supporting staff through salary, opportunities for advancement, and better supervision; requiring management to attend equity initiatives, and creating equity resources for staff.
This study provides a template for other evaluations of equity. Similar to other organizations in the field, this equity analysis suggests that PPLM had a stronger commitment to certain aspects of DEI than others, and that there was a need for improvement in several areas, particularly hiring and management.
展示对一家生殖健康协会进行公平性分析的过程和结果。
对马萨诸塞州计划生育联盟(PPLM)的员工进行了一系列定量调查和定性访谈,评估公平性的不同方面。外部咨询机构阿马卡咨询与评估服务有限责任公司分析了结果并提供了改进建议。
25%至33%的员工被认定为黑人、原住民和有色人种(BIPOC)。员工对该组织与使命的契合度以及对公平性的承诺表示高度满意。BIPOC员工的离职率较高,有色人种员工表示对高级管理层有信心的可能性较小。调查中频繁出现的主题包括需要加强围绕公平行动步骤的沟通、增强问责制以及工作环境问题。定性访谈表明认可多样性、公平性和包容性(DEI)方面的努力,但感觉这些努力不够合理,并表达了对更公平招聘的需求。改进建议包括跟踪围绕社会运动的反馈;进行公平性影响评估;通过薪资、晋升机会和更好的监督来支持员工;要求管理层参与公平性倡议,并为员工创建公平性资源。
本研究为其他公平性评估提供了一个模板。与该领域的其他组织类似,这项公平性分析表明,PPLM在DEI的某些方面比其他方面有更强的承诺,并且在几个领域需要改进,特别是招聘和管理方面。