Nahman Ornit, Few-Cooper Timothy J, Shen-Orr Shai S
Department of Immunology, Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, 1 Efron St., Haifa, 3525433, Israel.
Brief Bioinform. 2024 Nov 22;26(1). doi: 10.1093/bib/bbae621.
Spatial transcriptomics (ST), a breakthrough technology, captures the complex structure and state of tissues through the spatial profiling of gene expression. A variety of ST technologies have now emerged, most prominently spot-based platforms such as Visium. Despite the widespread use of ST and its distinct data characteristics, the vast majority of studies continue to analyze ST data using algorithms originally designed for older technologies such as single-cell (SC) and bulk RNA-seq-particularly when identifying differentially expressed genes (DEGs). However, it remains unclear whether these algorithms are still valid or appropriate for ST data. Therefore, here, we sought to characterize the performance of these methods by constructing an in silico simulator of ST data with a controllable and known DEG ground truth. Surprisingly, our findings reveal little variation in the performance of classic DEG algorithms-all of which fail to accurately recapture known DEGs to significant levels. We further demonstrate that cellular heterogeneity within spots is a primary cause of this poor performance and propose a simple gene-selection scheme, based on prior knowledge of cell-type specificity, to overcome this. Notably, our approach outperforms existing data-driven methods designed specifically for ST data and offers improved DEG recovery and reliability rates. In summary, our work details a conceptual framework that can be used upstream, agnostically, of any DEG algorithm to improve the accuracy of ST analysis and any downstream findings.
空间转录组学(ST)是一项突破性技术,它通过基因表达的空间分析来捕捉组织的复杂结构和状态。现在已经出现了多种ST技术,最突出的是基于斑点的平台,如Visium。尽管ST被广泛使用且具有独特的数据特征,但绝大多数研究在分析ST数据时,仍继续使用最初为单细胞(SC)和批量RNA测序等旧技术设计的算法,尤其是在识别差异表达基因(DEG)时。然而,这些算法对ST数据是否仍然有效或适用尚不清楚。因此,在此我们试图通过构建一个具有可控且已知DEG真值的ST数据计算机模拟来表征这些方法的性能。令人惊讶的是,我们的研究结果显示经典DEG算法的性能几乎没有差异——所有这些算法都未能准确地将已知DEG重新捕获到显著水平。我们进一步证明斑点内的细胞异质性是造成这种性能不佳的主要原因,并基于细胞类型特异性的先验知识提出了一种简单的基因选择方案来克服这一问题。值得注意的是,我们的方法优于专门为ST数据设计的现有数据驱动方法,并提高了DEG恢复率和可靠性。总之,我们的工作详细阐述了一个概念框架,该框架可在任何DEG算法的上游、无关地使用,以提高ST分析的准确性和任何下游结果。