Harrison Olivia K, Köchli Laura, Marino Stephanie, Marlow Lucy, Finnegan Sarah L, Ainsworth Ben, Talks Benjamin J, Russell Bruce R, Harrison Samuel J, Pattinson Kyle T S, Fleming Stephen M, Stephan Klaas E
Department of Psychology, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Eur J Neurosci. 2025 Jan;61(1):e16672. doi: 10.1111/ejn.16672.
Anxiety is one of the most common and debilitating mental health disorders, and is related to changes in interoception (perception of bodily states). While anxiety is more prevalent in women than men, gender differences in interoception-anxiety associations are often overlooked. Here, we examined gender-specific relationships between anxiety and interoception in the breathing domain, utilising multicentre data pooled from four study sites (N = 175; 51% women). State anxiety scores were quantified via the Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, and breathing-related interoceptive dimensions via an inspiratory load task to quantify sensitivity, decision bias, metacognitive bias (confidence in interoceptive decisions), and metacognitive insight (congruency between performance and confidence). Regression analyses revealed a significant negative relationship between state anxiety and metacognitive bias (β = -0.28; p = 0.01) and insight (β = -0.09; 95% highest density interval [HDI] in a hierarchical Bayesian regression = [-0.18, -0.004]) across the whole sample, while state anxiety did not relate to interoceptive sensitivity nor decision bias. While no mean interoceptive effects relating to gender were observed, the relationship between anxiety and metacognitive insight towards breathing was driven by women (women: β = -0.18; HDI = [-0.31, -0.05]; men: β = 0.02; HDI = [-0.12, 0.15]) with a significant interaction effect (β difference = -0.20; HDI = [-0.37, -0.01]), which did not hold for trait anxiety nor depression measures. In summary, state anxiety was associated with decreased metacognitive bias across all participants, while decreased interoceptive insight was only associated with anxiety in women but not men. Therefore, treatment programmes focusing on interoceptive metacognitive bias may be useful for all anxiety patients, while interoceptive insight might represent a specific treatment target for women with anxiety.
焦虑是最常见且使人衰弱的心理健康障碍之一,与内感受(对身体状态的感知)变化有关。虽然焦虑在女性中比男性更普遍,但内感受与焦虑关联中的性别差异常常被忽视。在此,我们利用从四个研究地点汇总的多中心数据(N = 175;51%为女性),研究了呼吸领域中焦虑与内感受的性别特异性关系。通过斯皮尔伯格状态 - 特质焦虑量表对状态焦虑得分进行量化,通过吸气负荷任务对与呼吸相关的内感受维度进行量化,以量化敏感性、决策偏差、元认知偏差(对内感受决策的信心)和元认知洞察力(表现与信心之间的一致性)。回归分析显示,在整个样本中,状态焦虑与元认知偏差(β = -0.28;p = 0.01)和洞察力(β = -0.09;分层贝叶斯回归中的95%最高密度区间[HDI] = [-0.18, -0.004])之间存在显著负相关,而状态焦虑与内感受敏感性和决策偏差无关。虽然未观察到与性别相关的平均内感受效应,但焦虑与对呼吸的元认知洞察力之间的关系由女性驱动(女性:β = -0.18;HDI = [-0.31, -0.05];男性:β = 0.02;HDI = [-0.12, 0.15]),具有显著的交互效应(β差异 = -0.20;HDI = [-0.37, -0.01]),特质焦虑和抑郁测量指标不存在这种情况。总之,状态焦虑与所有参与者的元认知偏差降低有关,而内感受洞察力降低仅与女性而非男性的焦虑有关。因此,专注于内感受元认知偏差的治疗方案可能对所有焦虑患者有用,而内感受洞察力可能是焦虑女性的特定治疗靶点。