Spee Blanca T M, Stap Thieme B, Plijnaer Marjoke, Pasman Gert, Zeggio Sara, Duits Annelien, Crone Julia S, Haeyen Suzanne, Pelowski Matthew, Bloem Bastiaan R, Koksma Jan-Jurjen
Department of Neurology, Radboud University Medical Centre, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Centre of Expertise for Parkinson and Movement Disorders, Nijmegen, Netherlands.
Vienna Cognitive Science Hub, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Front Psychol. 2025 Jan 15;15:1469120. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1469120. eCollection 2024.
Recent research in the field of "Arts and Health" has demonstrated the beneficial impact of arts-based interventions on health and well-being across diverse populations. Recognizing their potential, especially in cases where conventional healthcare cannot address the multifaceted impact of conditions such as in Parkinson's disease (PD), our study advocates for an integrative approach in medical practice and neuroscience. We recommend incorporating learning environments from the design phase through long-term care. The arts offer a unique opportunity to create such environments. In this study, we specifically focus on individuals with PD, co-designing an intervention as a creative engagement learning environment and a PD-specific creative arts therapy. In this study, the narratives of those affected contribute as scientific knowledge, shaping care and increasing the intervention's relevance to participants' lives.
We used a participatory design-based research approach. Fourteen individuals with PD, along with three creative therapists and three researchers, collaborated through iterative design cycles to co-develop a creative arts therapy intervention. Qualitative data were collected through interviews, group reflections, and ethnographic observations. Data were analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis.
The co-creation process resulted in a 10-week creative engagement intervention delivered in a "creative playground" setting. Participants chose from multiple media and autonomously decided their creative activities. Guidance from the creative therapists was provided as needed to support individual engagement and guide reflection and learning processes. Narratives offered insights into the relevance of autonomy in care, the role of the arts, and the individuality of disease experience, resulting in seven key features of our intervention framework, which include (i) intervention structure (e.g., duration of the intervention and sessions), (ii) freedom in selection of creative media, (iii) environment as a creative playground, (iv) skills of creative therapists, (v) PD-specific considerations, (vi) financial considerations and logistics, and we list (vii) responsibilities of the Design Team.
This study establishes an initial framework for a PD-specific creative arts therapy intervention designed as a creative engagement learning environment. Future research will focus on rigorously evaluating its effectiveness and exploring its scalability in diverse settings.
“艺术与健康”领域的近期研究表明,基于艺术的干预措施对不同人群的健康和幸福具有有益影响。认识到其潜力,特别是在传统医疗保健无法解决帕金森病(PD)等病症的多方面影响的情况下,我们的研究倡导在医疗实践和神经科学中采用综合方法。我们建议从设计阶段到长期护理都纳入学习环境。艺术为创造这样的环境提供了独特的机会。在本研究中,我们特别关注帕金森病患者,共同设计一种干预措施,作为一种创造性参与学习环境和针对帕金森病的创造性艺术疗法。在本研究中,受影响者的叙述作为科学知识发挥作用,塑造护理方式并提高干预措施与参与者生活的相关性。
我们采用基于参与式设计的研究方法。14名帕金森病患者与3名创意治疗师和3名研究人员通过迭代设计周期合作,共同开发一种创造性艺术疗法干预措施。通过访谈、小组反思和民族志观察收集定性数据。使用反思性主题分析对数据进行分析。
共同创作过程产生了一项为期10周的创造性参与干预措施,在“创意游乐场”环境中实施。参与者从多种媒介中进行选择,并自主决定他们的创造性活动。根据需要提供创意治疗师的指导,以支持个人参与并指导反思和学习过程。叙述提供了关于护理中自主性的相关性、艺术的作用以及疾病体验的个体性的见解,从而形成了我们干预框架的七个关键特征,其中包括:(i)干预结构(例如,干预和课程的持续时间),(ii)选择创意媒介的自由度,(iii)作为创意游乐场的环境,(iv)创意治疗师的技能,(v)针对帕金森病的考虑因素,(vi)财务考虑因素和后勤保障,我们列出(vii)设计团队的职责。
本研究为作为创造性参与学习环境设计的针对帕金森病的创造性艺术疗法干预措施建立了一个初步框架。未来的研究将专注于严格评估其有效性,并探索其在不同环境中的可扩展性。