Casanova Oscar, Riaño María Elena, Zarza-Alzugaray Francisco Javier, Orejudo Santos
Department of Musical, Plastic and Body Expression, University of Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain.
Department of Education, University of Cantabria, Santander, Spain.
Front Psychol. 2025 Feb 10;16:1515970. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1515970. eCollection 2025.
Musical Performance Anxiety (MPA) is one of the major obstacles many musicians face in the course of their training and careers. Few studies have approached this construct using a qualitative methodology. To apply such an approach, we gathered testimonials of life histories from four musicians - two pianists, a violinist, and a cellist - through semi-structured interviews. With an average age of 25, they had all studied classical music for at least 10 years. We subjected the protocols of those interviews to a phase and categorization process based on Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. The first years of training were those when our interviewees recalled experiencing the greatest enjoyment in music-making: positive elements included family support, ensemble playing, and initial encounters with non-classical repertoire and improvisation. However, as our interviewees progressed through their academic courses and improved in terms of mastery of their instrument, they began to experience situations of anxiety. Physical symptoms appeared, regularly associated with situations such as examinations and auditions in front of a jury. Two of four respondents decided to terminate their music training before entering university level. To deal with symptoms of anxiety, several approaches were pursued: visualization, cognitive analysis, and self-medication. However, to mitigate MPA, our informants generally recommend more rational strategies: a realistic focus on objectives coupled with reinforcement of self-esteem. Institutions of musical learning can help students cope with this disorder by encouraging musical creativity and selecting educators who apply empathetic teaching styles well-adapted to their pupils' needs. In the future, this type of qualitative research can be expanded to a greater number of informants with more diverse characteristics. The qualitative approach will help us to better understand the MPA phenomenon.
音乐表演焦虑(MPA)是许多音乐家在训练和职业生涯中面临的主要障碍之一。很少有研究采用定性方法来探讨这一概念。为了应用这种方法,我们通过半结构化访谈收集了四位音乐家——两位钢琴家、一位小提琴家和一位大提琴家——的生活史证词。他们的平均年龄为25岁,都学习古典音乐至少10年。我们根据解释现象学分析,对这些访谈记录进行了阶段划分和分类处理。训练的最初几年是受访者回忆起在音乐创作中体验到最大乐趣的时期:积极因素包括家庭支持、合奏演奏,以及初次接触非古典曲目和即兴演奏。然而,随着受访者在学业课程中不断进步,并且在乐器掌握方面有所提高,他们开始经历焦虑的情况。身体症状出现了,通常与考试和面对评审团的试听等情况有关。四位受访者中有两位在进入大学阶段之前决定终止音乐训练。为了应对焦虑症状,他们采取了几种方法:可视化、认知分析和自我治疗。然而,为了减轻音乐表演焦虑,我们的受访者普遍推荐更理性的策略:切实关注目标并增强自尊。音乐学习机构可以通过鼓励音乐创造力和挑选善于运用适合学生需求的移情教学风格的教育工作者,来帮助学生应对这种障碍。未来,这种定性研究可以扩展到更多具有更多样化特征的受访者。定性方法将帮助我们更好地理解音乐表演焦虑现象。