Mai Margot, Molina Rose L, Aguayo-Mazzucato Cristina, Diaz Alejandro A, Canenguez Katia, Cheung Hong Chen, Graupera Nina Rivera, Martel Brandon, Bonilla Silvana
Third-Year Medical Student, Harvard Medical School; Fourth-Year Doctoral Student, Department of Anthropology, Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.
Assistant Professor of Obstetrics, Gynecology & Reproductive Biology, Harvard Medical School; Physician, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center.
MedEdPORTAL. 2025 Apr 17;21:11518. doi: 10.15766/mep_2374-8265.11518. eCollection 2025.
Few standardized assessments exist for evaluating medical students' oral Spanish communication with patients. Educators in Medical Spanish need practical, accessible tools. We designed and implemented a standardized clinical case-based assessment to evaluate students' oral Spanish communication skills upon course conclusion.
The students enrolled in the Intermediate and Advanced Medical Spanish courses during the Fall 2021 term were included. Students participated in a standardized clinical case-based assessment with a standardized patient. The students' performance was evaluated using scoring of a binary checklist focused on 20 key components of the medical interview in Spanish, and 2 formative feedback items about their Spanish language skills.
Twenty-eight students participated in the educational activity, including 13 from the Intermediate and 15 from the Advanced Medical Spanish courses. Of the participants, 43% ( = 12) were female, 89% ( = 25) were medical students and 11% ( = 3) were dental students, and 78% ( = 22) were first-year students at Harvard Medical School. Overall, students in both the Intermediate and Advanced levels achieved high aggregate performance scores, at or above 80%. Mean scores differed between the two groups ( = .0001).
The standardized clinical case-based assessment effectively evaluated students' communication skills upon completing the longitudinal Medical Spanish course. It helped students ask key medical history questions in Spanish. Our curriculum offers a standardized patient case as a model for other instructors to assess oral medical Spanish communication skills.
用于评估医学生与患者进行西班牙语口语交流的标准化评估很少。医学西班牙语教育工作者需要实用且易于使用的工具。我们设计并实施了一项基于标准化临床病例的评估,以在课程结束时评估学生的西班牙语口语交流技能。
纳入了2021年秋季学期参加中级和高级医学西班牙语课程的学生。学生与标准化患者一起参与了一项基于标准化临床病例的评估。使用一份二元检查表进行评分来评估学生的表现,该检查表侧重于西班牙语医学问诊的20个关键组成部分,以及关于他们西班牙语语言技能的2个形成性反馈项目。
28名学生参与了这项教育活动,其中13名来自中级医学西班牙语课程,15名来自高级医学西班牙语课程。在参与者中,43%(=12)为女性,89%(=25)是医学生,11%(=3)是牙科学生,78%(=22)是哈佛医学院的一年级学生。总体而言,中级和高级水平的学生都取得了较高的综合成绩,达到或超过了80%。两组的平均成绩存在差异(=0.0001)。
基于标准化临床病例的评估在纵向医学西班牙语课程结束时有效地评估了学生的沟通技能。它帮助学生用西班牙语询问关键的病史问题。我们的课程提供了一个标准化患者病例,作为其他教师评估医学西班牙语口语交流技能的模型。