Nolan James M, Skujina Ilze, Hurpy Gwenaëlle, Tighe Andrew J, Whelan Conor, Teeling Emma C
School of Biology and Environmental Science University College Dublin Dublin 4 Ireland.
School of Biological and Chemical Sciences University of Galway Galway Ireland.
Ecol Evol. 2025 May 4;15(5):e71333. doi: 10.1002/ece3.71333. eCollection 2025 May.
Biodiversity monitoring using metabarcoding is now widely used as a routine environmental management tool. However, despite the rapid advancement of third-generation high-throughput sequencing platforms, there are limited studies assessing the most suitable tools and approaches for environmental metabarcoding studies. We tested the utility of Oxford Nanopore Technologies MinION sequencing for short-read amplicon sequencing of mitochondrial mini-barcodes from a known composition of arthropod species and compared its performance with more commonly used Illumina NovaSeq sequencing. The mock arthropod species assemblage allowed us to optimise a bioinformatic filtering pipeline to identify arthropod species using MinION long reads. Using this pipeline, we identified host species and diet composition by sequencing droppings collected from five individual Irish brown long-eared bats () roosts. We showed that MinION data provided a similar taxonomic assignment to but only if the reference species barcode database was accurate and comprehensive. The diet inferred was as expected based on previous morphological and Illumina metabarcoding studies. We showed that less sequencing depth, but a higher number of biological samples were necessary for complete species composition detection by MinION. A relatively simple bioinformatic filtering tool such as NanoPipe could adequately retrieve both host species and diet composition. The biggest standing challenge was the reference database format transferability and comprehensiveness. This pipeline can be used to guide future metabarcoding studies using nanopore sequencing to minimise the cost and effort while optimising results.
利用宏条形码进行生物多样性监测现已广泛用作一种常规环境管理工具。然而,尽管第三代高通量测序平台发展迅速,但评估环境宏条形码研究最合适工具和方法的研究却很有限。我们测试了牛津纳米孔技术公司的MinION测序技术用于对已知节肢动物物种组成的线粒体微型条形码进行短读长扩增子测序的效用,并将其性能与更常用的Illumina NovaSeq测序进行了比较。模拟节肢动物物种组合使我们能够优化一个生物信息过滤流程,以便使用MinION长读长识别节肢动物物种。利用这个流程,我们通过对从五只爱尔兰棕长耳蝠()栖息地收集的粪便进行测序,确定了宿主物种和饮食组成。我们表明,MinION数据提供了与类似的分类学归属,但前提是参考物种条形码数据库准确且全面。根据先前的形态学和Illumina宏条形码研究,推断出的饮食情况符合预期。我们表明,对于通过MinION进行完整物种组成检测而言,测序深度较低,但需要更多生物样本。像NanoPipe这样相对简单的生物信息过滤工具能够充分检索宿主物种和饮食组成。最大的持续挑战是参考数据库格式的可转移性和全面性。这个流程可用于指导未来使用纳米孔测序的宏条形码研究,在优化结果的同时尽量降低成本和工作量。