Brazier Caroline Éliane, Masdonati Jonas, Parmentier Michaël
Research Center in Vocational Psychology and Career Counseling (CEPCO), Institute of Psychology, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Swiss National Centre of Competence in Research LIVES - Overcoming Vulnerability: Life Course perspectives (NCCR LIVES), University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
J Career Assess. 2025 Aug;33(3):592-613. doi: 10.1177/10690727241289126. Epub 2024 Oct 1.
Although extensive research on career transitions exists, little is known about the challenges and processes of involuntary career change. Building on Savickas's theoretical framework of objective and subjective careers, we investigated the subjective experiences of involuntary career changes while apprehending their objective unfolding. Following a longitudinal qualitative design, we conducted two waves of semistructured interviews with 18 participants who had been forced to change careers due to health issues, migration, or saturated labor market in Switzerland. A four-step temporal thematic analysis covering case description, case comparison, case processes analysis, and processes comparison highlighted a spectrum of career change processes. At one end, individuals experienced synchronous progressions and regained meaning and control over their career combined with a rather linear status sequence. Conversely, some individuals underwent asynchronous developments consisting of either modest objective steps that instigated meaningful subjective experiences or status stagnation, leading to a loss of control and meaning. These findings underscore the variety of involuntary career change processes and unveil synchronicity as a key temporal element in involuntary career change processes. Implications for research and practice are discussed.
尽管对职业转型已有广泛研究,但对于非自愿职业变动的挑战和过程却知之甚少。基于萨维卡斯的客观和主观职业生涯理论框架,我们在了解非自愿职业变动客观发展情况的同时,对其主观体验进行了调查。遵循纵向定性设计,我们对18名因健康问题、移民或瑞士劳动力市场饱和而被迫改变职业的参与者进行了两轮半结构化访谈。一个涵盖案例描述、案例比较、案例过程分析和过程比较的四步时间主题分析突出了一系列职业变动过程。一方面,个体经历同步发展,重新获得对其职业的意义感和掌控力,同时伴随着较为线性的地位序列。相反,一些个体经历了异步发展,包括引发有意义主观体验的适度客观进展或地位停滞,导致失去掌控力和意义感。这些发现强调了非自愿职业变动过程的多样性,并揭示同步性是非自愿职业变动过程中的一个关键时间要素。文中还讨论了对研究和实践的启示。