Chi Chen-Hsiang, Peng Guan-Ju, Day Yuan-Ji, Hsu Che-Hao, Sheen Michael J
Department of Anesthesiology, Tungs' Taichung MetroHarbor Hospital, Taichung, Taiwan.
Graduate Institute of Data Science and Information Computing, National Chung Hsing University, No.145, Xingda Rd., South Dist., Taichung City, 402, Taiwan (R.O.C.).
J Anesth. 2025 Jun 16. doi: 10.1007/s00540-025-03527-5.
Forecasting the depth of anesthesia (DOA) is significant for adjusting the dosage of propofol infusion during total intravenous anesthesia. Traditional pharmacokinetic (PK) and pharmacodynamic (PD) models may lack precision in DOA forecasting. Thus, machine learning models optimized to fit the clinical data have been adopted to predict the DOA, showing improved accuracy. These earlier approaches followed the recurrent and/or the feed-forward framework that generates the predictions based on the patient's demographic data. In this work, to explore the potential advantages of using real-time information in DOA forecasting, we proposed using the auto-regressive (AR) frameworks to improve the accuracy of DOA prediction during the induction phase of anesthesia.
This study employed two auto-regressive frameworks, intra-loop auto-regressive (ILAR) and real-time auto-regressive (RTAR), respectively, for two different scenarios, with an attention mechanism to predict the DOA during the induction phase. The profiles of 528 patients were considered to forecast the DOA values within the induction phase. 80% (433 patients) of the data were randomly selected for training, while the remaining 105 were used for validation. The model's performance was evaluated using metrics including absolute median performance error (MDAPE), median performance error (MDPE), and root mean square error (RMSE). To assess the performance of our approach, we compared it with a conventional feed-forward framework.
The experimental results indicated that the proposed auto-regressive approach outperformed the framework comprising recurrent and feed-forward networks (implemented using the LSTM, followed by the MLP networks in this paper) in predicting the DOA of the induction phase. The MDAPE values of our ILAR and RTAR frameworks were, respectively, 2.5% and 11.6%; in contrast, the value of the LSTM-MLP framework was 17.7%. With the real-time bispectral Index (BIS) values, the RTAR framework significantly outperforms the LSTM-MLP framework, achieving the least MDAPE and RMSE values and obtaining the closest to zero MDPE values. When the real-time BIS values are unavailable, the proposed ILAR framework has much lower MDAPE values and closer to zero MDPE values than the LSTM-MLP framework.
We proposed two auto-regressive frameworks, the ILAR and the RTAR, to predict the DOA values in the induction phase of the anesthetic period. The proposed ILAR and the RTAR can be used to predict the DOA for the two scenarios, depending on whether the sensor can observe the real-time BIS values. The experimental results demonstrated that the BIS values forecast by the proposed approaches were significantly closer to the ground truth than the previous LSTM-MLP framework.
预测麻醉深度(DOA)对于在全静脉麻醉期间调整丙泊酚输注剂量具有重要意义。传统的药代动力学(PK)和药效动力学(PD)模型在DOA预测中可能缺乏精度。因此,已采用优化以拟合临床数据的机器学习模型来预测DOA,显示出更高的准确性。这些早期方法遵循基于患者人口统计学数据生成预测的循环和/或前馈框架。在这项工作中,为了探索在DOA预测中使用实时信息的潜在优势,我们提出使用自回归(AR)框架来提高麻醉诱导期DOA预测的准确性。
本研究分别针对两种不同场景采用了两种自回归框架,即环内自回归(ILAR)和实时自回归(RTAR),并采用注意力机制来预测诱导期的DOA。考虑了528例患者的资料来预测诱导期内的DOA值。随机选择80%(433例患者)的数据用于训练,其余105例用于验证。使用包括绝对中位数性能误差(MDAPE)、中位数性能误差(MDPE)和均方根误差(RMSE)等指标来评估模型的性能。为了评估我们方法的性能,我们将其与传统的前馈框架进行了比较。
实验结果表明,所提出的自回归方法在预测诱导期的DOA方面优于由循环和前馈网络组成的框架(本文中使用LSTM,随后是MLP网络实现)。我们的ILAR和RTAR框架的MDAPE值分别为2.5%和11.6%;相比之下,LSTM-MLP框架的值为17.7%。对于实时脑电双频指数(BIS)值,RTAR框架显著优于LSTM-MLP框架,实现了最小的MDAPE和RMSE值,并获得了最接近零的MDPE值。当无法获得实时BIS值时,所提出的ILAR框架的MDAPE值比LSTM-MLP框架低得多,且更接近零MDPE值。
我们提出了两种自回归框架,即ILAR和RTAR,以预测麻醉期诱导期的DOA值。根据传感器是否能观察到实时BIS值,所提出的ILAR和RTAR可用于预测两种场景下的DOA。实验结果表明,所提出方法预测的BIS值比先前的LSTM-MLP框架显著更接近真实值。