Ameli Nazila, Miri Moghaddam Masoud, Lai Hollis, Pacheco-Pereira Camila
Mike Petryk School of Dentistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Imaging Sci Dent. 2025 Jun;55(2):175-188. doi: 10.5624/isd.20240232. Epub 2025 Apr 10.
Panoramic radiographs are instrumental in dental diagnosis but face quality issues related to contrast, artifacts, positioning, and coverage, which can impact diagnostic accuracy. Although expert assessment is the accepted standard, it is time-consuming and prone to inconsistency. Artificial intelligence offers an automated, objective solution for evaluating radiograph quality, increasing efficiency and reducing inter-rater variability.
This study aimed to develop a deep learning (DL)-based model for evaluating the quality of dental panoramic radiographs. A dataset of 1,000 panoramic images, collected from 2018 to 2023, was assessed by 2 trained dentists using predefined grading criteria for contrast/density, artifact presence, coverage area, patient positioning, and overall quality. These expert-annotated scores were used as the ground truth to train and validate 5 YOLOv8 classification models, each targeting a specific quality criterion. The models' performance was evaluated on a separate test set using performance metrics.
The YOLOv8 models achieved classification accuracies of 87.2%, 74.1%, 77.3%, 97.9%, and 79.3% for artifact detection, coverage area, patient positioning, contrast/density, and overall image quality, respectively. The model used to classify images as clinically acceptable or unacceptable exhibited an average accuracy of 81.4%, demonstrating its potential for real-world application.
These findings highlight the feasibility of DL-based automated image quality assessment for panoramic radiographs. The high accuracy of the proposed model suggests its potential integration into clinical workflows to assist practitioners in efficiently evaluating radiograph quality. Additionally, such a model could represent an educational tool for dental students, improving radiographic techniques and reducing unnecessary retakes.
全景X线片在牙科诊断中发挥着重要作用,但存在对比度、伪影、定位和覆盖范围等质量问题,这些问题会影响诊断准确性。尽管专家评估是公认的标准,但它既耗时又容易出现不一致性。人工智能为评估X线片质量提供了一种自动化、客观的解决方案,可提高效率并减少评分者间的变异性。
本研究旨在开发一种基于深度学习(DL)的模型,用于评估牙科全景X线片的质量。收集了2018年至2023年的1000张全景图像数据集,由2名经过培训的牙医使用针对对比度/密度、伪影存在、覆盖区域、患者定位和整体质量的预定义分级标准进行评估。这些专家标注的分数被用作训练和验证5个YOLOv8分类模型的基本事实,每个模型针对一个特定的质量标准。使用性能指标在单独的测试集上评估模型的性能。
YOLOv8模型在伪影检测、覆盖区域、患者定位、对比度/密度和整体图像质量方面的分类准确率分别为87.2%、74.1%、77.3%、97.9%和79.3%。用于将图像分类为临床可接受或不可接受的模型平均准确率为81.4%,表明其在实际应用中的潜力。
这些发现突出了基于深度学习的全景X线片自动图像质量评估的可行性。所提出模型的高准确率表明其有可能集成到临床工作流程中,以帮助从业者有效评估X线片质量。此外,这样的模型可以成为牙科学生的教育工具,改进X线摄影技术并减少不必要的重新拍摄。