Huang Shuo Jim, Yue Dahai, White Whilby Kellee, Boudreaux Michel, McCoy Rozalina G, Robinson-Ector Kaitlynn S, Sehgal Neil J
medRxiv. 2025 Jun 30:2025.06.28.25330483. doi: 10.1101/2025.06.28.25330483.
Background Historical redlining policies enacted in the 1930s and 1940s that restricted investment in Black neighborhoods shaped neighborhood conditions that may contribute to inequities in health and mortality among older adults today. Areas "redlined" by the Home Owners' Loan Corporation (HOLC) in the 1930s against Black neighborhoods are associated with worse present-day area-level health outcomes. We examined whether early, personal exposure to redlining close to when the maps were drawn is associated with individual-level mortality hazard (survival time ratio) and self-rated health in older adults. Methods We used mapped 1940 census enumeration districts to assign 1930s HOLC redlining categories (green A ("best"), blue B ("still desirable"), yellow C ("definitely declining"), and red D ("hazardous")) to Health and Retirement Study participants based on 1940 census residence. We applied survey weights and ran a survival analysis with a parametric normal distribution maximum likelihood estimation to account for survivorship bias, and logistic regression on self-rated health, and included analyses stratified by race. Results 1940 HOLC-categorized yellow C (0.62 times the survival time, 95% CI: 0.41, 0.92) and red D (red: 0.59, 95% CI: 0.40, 0.87) exposures were significantly associated with reduced survival time compared to green A in both unadjusted and adjusted models. In stratified analyses, both Black and white residents of redlined areas had worse survival time ratios compared to green A, though the magnitude of effect was larger for Black residents than for white residents. Yellow C (Odds Ratio: 1.94, 95% CI: 1.16, 3.23) and red D (2.34, 95% CI: 1.37, 3.98) areas were also associated with increased odds of worse self-rated health compared to green A areas. Discussion Living in redlined areas in the 1940s is associated with worse mortality survival for both Black and white older adults and with decreased self-rated health in older adults between 1992 and 2018. These findings extend beyond broader prior research demonstrating present-day area-level associations of redlining with worse health and are consistent with prior research on individual-level exposure to redlining. Associations with worse mortality in both Black and white residents (with stronger effects in Black residents) are consistent with theory and research demonstrating that structural racism degrades health for all communities.
20世纪30年代和40年代实施的历史上的红线划定政策限制了对黑人社区的投资,塑造了邻里环境,这可能导致如今老年人在健康和死亡率方面的不平等。20世纪30年代被房主贷款公司(HOLC)划定为针对黑人社区的“红线”区域与当今更差的区域层面健康结果相关。我们研究了在地图绘制后不久就早期个人接触红线划定是否与老年人的个体层面死亡风险(生存时间比)和自我评估健康状况相关。
我们使用1940年人口普查枚举区地图,根据1940年的人口普查居住地,为健康与退休研究的参与者分配20世纪30年代HOLC的红线划定类别(绿色A(“最佳”)、蓝色B(“仍然理想”)、黄色C(“肯定在衰退”)和红色D(“危险”))。我们应用调查权重,并进行了参数正态分布最大似然估计的生存分析以考虑生存偏差,以及对自我评估健康进行逻辑回归,并纳入了按种族分层的分析。
在未调整和调整模型中,与绿色A相比,1940年HOLC分类为黄色C(生存时间为0.62倍,95%置信区间:0.41,0.92)和红色D(红色:0.59,95%置信区间:0.40,0.87)的暴露与生存时间缩短显著相关。在分层分析中,与绿色A相比,红线划定区域的黑人和白人居民的生存时间比都更差,尽管黑人居民的影响程度比白人居民更大。与绿色A区域相比,黄色C(优势比:1.94,95%置信区间:1.16,3.23)和红色D(2.34,95%置信区间:1.37,3.98)区域也与自我评估健康状况较差的几率增加相关。
20世纪40年代生活在红线划定区域与黑人和白人老年人更差的死亡率生存以及1992年至2018年老年人自我评估健康状况下降相关。这些发现超越了先前更广泛的研究,这些研究表明当今红线划定与更差健康状况的区域层面关联,并且与先前关于个人层面接触红线划定的研究一致。黑人和白人居民中与更差死亡率的关联(黑人居民中影响更强)与理论和研究一致,这些理论和研究表明结构性种族主义会损害所有社区的健康。