Brown Rachel, Anthony Rebecca, Eyre Olga, Lennon Jessica, Powell Vicky, Haslam Zoe, Rowe Abbey, Moore Graham
Wolfson Centre for Young People's Mental Health, Spark, Cardiff University, Maindy Road, Cardiff, CF24 4HQ UK.
DECIPHer, Spark, Cardiff University, Maindy Road, Cardiff, CF24 4HQ UK.
School Ment Health. 2025;17(2):486-494. doi: 10.1007/s12310-024-09740-z. Epub 2025 Jan 8.
In 2021, the Welsh Government introduced new statutory guidance for schools titled 'Framework Guidance on Embedding a Whole School Approach to Emotional and Mental Wellbeing'. This document outlined new responsibilities for educational settings to work towards incorporating a whole school approach, with regard to the Framework in action planning, service delivery and policy in relation to the mental and emotional wellbeing of learners and staff. While there is growing evidence to suggest that whole school approaches can be beneficial to social and emotional wellbeing for pupils, evidence on effective implementation is limited. This paper reports on findings from qualitative group interviews with staff in schools in Wales, conducted as part of a wider, mixed-methods evaluation of the Framework. It focuses on factors in the school context which impacted initial implementation. A number of school level factors were identified as barriers to implementation and staff engagement with the Framework. School staff reported higher levels of pupil mental health challenges stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and an absence of capacity in in-house and external support services to address this. Poor staff wellbeing and significant workload pressures were also reported, driven in part by concurrent implementation of the new Curriculum For Wales. This led staff to feel ill-prepared for the more complex issues being faced, exacerbated by a lack of access to relevant training to be able to support pupil and colleague mental health. This paper concludes with recommendations for policy-makers to support Framework implementation.
2021年,威尔士政府为学校出台了新的法定指南,题为《将全校性方法融入情绪和心理健康的框架指南》。该文件概述了教育机构的新职责,即在行动计划、服务提供以及与学习者和教职员工的心理和情绪健康相关的政策方面,努力采用全校性方法。虽然越来越多的证据表明全校性方法对学生的社会和情绪健康有益,但关于有效实施的证据有限。本文报告了对威尔士学校工作人员进行定性小组访谈的结果,这些访谈是对该框架进行更广泛的混合方法评估的一部分。它关注学校环境中影响初步实施的因素。一些学校层面的因素被确定为实施该框架以及工作人员参与该框架的障碍。学校工作人员报告称,由于新冠疫情,学生心理健康面临的挑战增多,而内部和外部支持服务都没有能力应对这一情况。还报告了工作人员的健康状况不佳和巨大的工作量压力,部分原因是同时实施了新的威尔士课程。这使得工作人员对面临的更复杂问题准备不足,而由于缺乏相关培训来支持学生和同事的心理健康,情况更加恶化。本文最后为政策制定者提供了支持框架实施的建议。