以用户为中心对结核病治疗支持数字工具进行优化:迭代式混合方法研究
User-Centered Refinement of a Digital Tool for Tuberculosis Treatment Support: Iterative Mixed Methods Study.
作者信息
Iribarren Sarah, Aguilar Vidrio Omar Alfonso, Roberti Javier, Goodwin Kyle, Chirico Cristina, Telles Hugo, Lutz Barry, Bornengo Fernanda, Rubinstein Fernando
机构信息
Department of Biobehavioral Nursing and Health Informatics, University of Washington, Health Science Building, T602C, Box 357266, 1959 NE Pacific Street, Seattle, WA, 98195, United States, 1 2065435211.
Centre for Research in Epidemiology and Public Health (CIESP), Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas, Ravignani 2024, Buenos Aires, 1414, Argentina, 54 47778767.
出版信息
J Med Internet Res. 2025 Jul 30;27:e76742. doi: 10.2196/76742.
BACKGROUND
Despite the potential of digital adherence technologies to support patient-centered monitoring for tuberculosis (TB), there is limited research on incorporating indirect and direct adherence monitoring or assessing patients' experiences with these technologies. The TB Treatment Support Tools (TB-TST) includes a comprehensive mobile app for patients and health care providers and a direct adherence metabolite test to report and monitor adherence.
OBJECTIVE
This paper describes the iterative refinement process of the TB-TST intervention.
METHODS
To refine the TB-TST intervention, we used an iterative approach involving multiple embedded mixed methods studies guided by the Information Systems Research framework and Design Thinking Process. Embedded studies included a randomized controlled pilot study, interviews, usability testing, and surveys with patients and experts to inform ongoing refinements. The project consisted of interface evaluation, high-level system design, and iterative redesign.
RESULTS
The TB-TST intervention was refined through 3 iterative phases. In Phase 1, based on feedback from pilot study participants and 4 experts in TB, improvements included an in-app discussion board, submission confirmations, and enhanced account recovery. Cultural adaptation was based on Hofstede's dimensions. Phase 2 involved 4 Directed Research Groups and 19 stakeholders to redesign user flows, simplify reporting, and transition the app to a progressive web app, improving device compatibility. Phase 3 included usability testing cycles with 48 participants (26 patients and 22 health care professionals), yielding high satisfaction scores: patient app Mobile Health App Usability Questionnaire, mean 5.96 (SD 0.46); provider mobile dashboard IT Usability Evaluation Scale scores ranged from 5.83 to 6.23 out of 7, and optimization of interface and dashboard. Refinements included larger icons, streamlined onboarding, symptom summary enhancements, and a new cohort-level adherence graph. These modifications improved navigation, usability, and remote monitoring for patients with TB and providers in preparation for a multisite clinical trial.
CONCLUSIONS
Combining multiple methods guided by the Information Systems Research framework and elements of the Design Thinking Process can help researchers and developers leverage the strengths of mixed methods iterative designs to create highly personalized and effective digital health interventions.
背景
尽管数字依从性技术有潜力支持以患者为中心的结核病监测,但在纳入间接和直接依从性监测或评估患者使用这些技术的体验方面,研究有限。结核病治疗支持工具(TB-TST)包括一个面向患者和医疗服务提供者的综合移动应用程序以及一项用于报告和监测依从性的直接依从性代谢物检测。
目的
本文描述了TB-TST干预措施的迭代优化过程。
方法
为了优化TB-TST干预措施,我们采用了一种迭代方法,涉及多个以信息系统研究框架和设计思维过程为指导的嵌入式混合方法研究。嵌入式研究包括一项随机对照试点研究、访谈、可用性测试以及对患者和专家的调查,以为持续优化提供信息。该项目包括界面评估、高级系统设计和迭代重新设计。
结果
TB-TST干预措施经过三个迭代阶段得到优化。在第一阶段,根据试点研究参与者和4位结核病专家的反馈,改进措施包括应用内讨论板、提交确认以及增强账户恢复功能。文化适应基于霍夫斯泰德的维度。第二阶段涉及4个定向研究小组和19名利益相关者,以重新设计用户流程、简化报告并将应用程序转变为渐进式网络应用程序,从而提高设备兼容性。第三阶段包括对48名参与者(26名患者和22名医疗专业人员)进行可用性测试周期,获得了较高的满意度评分:患者应用程序移动健康应用程序可用性问卷,平均5.96(标准差0.46);提供者移动仪表板IT可用性评估量表得分在7分制中从5.83到6.23不等,以及界面和仪表板的优化。改进措施包括更大的图标、简化的入职流程、症状总结增强以及新的队列级依从性图表。这些修改改善了结核病患者和提供者的导航、可用性和远程监测,为多中心临床试验做好准备。
结论
结合以信息系统研究框架为指导的多种方法和设计思维过程的要素,可以帮助研究人员和开发人员利用混合方法迭代设计的优势,创建高度个性化和有效的数字健康干预措施。