Yao Esther S, Meissel Kane, Atatoa Carr Polly, Bullen Pat, Peiris-John Roshini, Manuela Sam, Clark Terryann C
School of Nursing, Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
School of Learning, Development and Professional Practice, Faculty of Arts and Education, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
J R Soc N Z. 2025 Feb 25;55(6):1432-1451. doi: 10.1080/03036758.2025.2467275. eCollection 2025.
Ethnicity is an important variable in health and social science research, but working quantitatively with ethnicity data is complex because the construct is multifaceted, fluid, subjective, and political in nature. This necessitates careful consideration within the context of, and issues related to, the collection and classification of ethnicity data. Researchers' methodological decisions regarding ethnicity data can impact substantive research outcomes and implications for policy and practice. This critical review provides an overview of the conceptualisation and sociohistorical context of ethnicity, followed by a thorough discussion of the methodological issues in the collection and analysis of ethnicity data with a focus on the Aotearoa New Zealand context. It then offers comprehensive guidance and recommendations for quantitative researchers. With an emphasis on researcher criticality, reflexivity, and the importance of upholding the data sovereignty of Indigenous and minoritised ethnic groups, this review equips data users with the information needed to conduct ethical, equitable, robust, and scientifically-informed research involving ethnicity.
种族是健康与社会科学研究中的一个重要变量,但在对种族数据进行定量研究时却很复杂,因为这一概念在本质上具有多面性、流动性、主观性和政治性。这就需要在种族数据的收集和分类背景及相关问题中进行审慎思考。研究人员在种族数据方面的方法决策会影响实质性研究成果以及对政策和实践的影响。这篇批判性综述首先概述了种族的概念化及其社会历史背景,接着深入讨论了种族数据收集与分析中的方法问题,重点关注新西兰的情况。然后为定量研究人员提供了全面的指导和建议。本综述强调研究人员的批判性、反思性以及维护原住民和少数族裔群体数据主权的重要性,为数据使用者提供了开展涉及种族的符合伦理、公平、稳健且基于科学的研究所需的信息。