Graham Clare, Webster Anthony, Guerin Suzanne, Gaynor Keith
School on Psychology, University College Dublin, Dublin 4, Ireland.
Trim Adult Mental Health Service, HSE, Navan, Ireland.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2025 Jul;34(4):e70123. doi: 10.1111/inm.70123.
There has been a dramatic shortage of patient-focused research in the history of psychiatric inpatient treatment. This study aimed to explore the lived experience of a sample of inpatients of psychiatric hospitals in Ireland before the introduction of the Mental Health Act in 2001. Six adults (aged 40-73 years; M = 57) who had been inpatients in Irish psychiatric institutions were interviewed using a semi-structured format. The data were analysed using interpretative phenomenological analysis. The analysis yielded four Group Experiential Themes (GET): Within the Walls, the Treatment of Treatments, Relationship with Self and Identity as Patient, and Relationships and Ruptures. Each GET comprised two subthemes exploring the impact of participants' admission to a psychiatric hospital. Participants described a complex and ambivalent relationship to their psychiatric admission. The findings emphasised the need to understand the individuals' experiences and the societal and cultural context in which the admission occurred. The findings highlighted how historical psychiatric admissions impacted social identity and wellbeing. The findings have direct clinical implications. This cohort is aging and may require inpatient services in the form of nursing home care. For those who have experienced long-term psychiatric institutionalisation, it is important to tailor support for this group whose voices have not been heard until now.
在精神科住院治疗的历史中,以患者为中心的研究一直严重匮乏。本研究旨在探讨2001年《精神健康法》出台之前爱尔兰精神病院部分住院患者的生活经历。采用半结构化形式对6名曾在爱尔兰精神病机构住院的成年人(年龄40 - 73岁;平均年龄57岁)进行了访谈。使用解释现象学分析方法对数据进行了分析。分析得出了四个群体体验主题(GET):在院墙之内、治疗的治疗、作为患者的自我与身份关系以及人际关系与破裂。每个GET包含两个子主题,探讨参与者入住精神病院的影响。参与者描述了他们与精神科住院经历之间复杂且矛盾的关系。研究结果强调了理解个体经历以及入院时的社会和文化背景的必要性。研究结果突出了既往精神科住院经历如何影响社会身份和幸福感。研究结果具有直接的临床意义。这一群体正在老龄化,可能需要养老院护理形式的住院服务。对于那些经历过长期精神科机构化治疗的人来说,为这个至今声音未被倾听的群体量身定制支持措施非常重要。