De Silva Lizzie, Baysari Melissa, Keep Melanie, Kench Peter, Clarke Jillian
Discipline of Medical Imaging Science Sydney School of Health Sciences Faculty of Medicine and Health The University of Sydney, Susan Wakil Health Building, Camperdown Campus Camperdown New South Wales Australia.
Faculty of Medicine and Health Susan Wakil School of Nursing and Midwifery Sydney Nursing School The University of Sydney Sydney New South Wales Australia.
Public Health Chall. 2025 Aug 18;4(3):e70105. doi: 10.1002/puh2.70105. eCollection 2025 Sep.
There is a notable rise in patient-initiated imaging requests, with one possible reason being the increased availability of online health information. This study specifically examines the impact of patient-initiated radiological exams on radiologists. Exploring their perspectives on how GPs acquiescing to patients' medical imaging requests impacts healthcare resources and skew patients' expectations of the capabilities of radiological studies. The findings of this study are crucial for understanding the evolving dynamics of radiology practice and its challenges.
A comprehensive cross-sectional opinion survey was administered to radiologists in private multi-specialty medical centers across Australia between November 2023 and February 2024. The survey included structured and open-ended questions distributed via an intranet platform within the same company and reached a wide range of radiologists. A total of 37 survey responses were received from the 100 surveys sent to radiologists, resulting in a response rate of 37%. Of these, 10 provided incomplete responses, leaving 27 for analysis.
Nearly half of the participants (48%) had over 20 years of experience. The majority of radiologists self-reported X-rays (27%), ultrasounds (25%), and computed tomography (CT) scans (24%) as the most commonly requested non-indicated imaging studies. Radiologists attributed these requests to patients' exposure to online medical information and their desire for reassurance. Approximately 24% of radiological studies were deemed unnecessary due to a lack of correlation between clinical history and the imaging or procedure requested to address the clinical issue, with 30% of radiologists reporting feeling pressured by GPs and patients to expedite report completion. Proposed strategies included patient education, communication, and the establishment of clear guidelines.
The study highlights the potential for a growing burden of patient-initiated imaging on radiologists. This burden is further compounded by patients' unrealistic expectations and lack of understanding of diagnostic imaging's limitations, as considered by those surveyed. Radiologists have stressed the crucial role of the broader healthcare context in collaborating with such requests. Patient education was emphasisX-ed to reduce unnecessary imaging and manage patient expectations.
Educating patients about the limitations and appropriate use of diagnostic imaging can help reduce unwarranted requests and manage patient expectations. The study emphasises the need for clear, evidence-based guidelines to assist GPs in addressing patient demands for unnecessary imaging studies. Another contribution from the study is the necessity for improved communication strategies among radiologists, GPs, and patients to ensure a collaborative approach to imaging requests, thereby reducing pressure on the radiologists' workload. Finally, this study highlights how avoiding unnecessary imaging can alleviate resource strain, optimise workflows, and enhance the quality of patient care.
患者主动发起的影像检查请求显著增加,一个可能的原因是在线健康信息的可获取性提高。本研究专门考察患者主动发起的放射学检查对放射科医生的影响。探讨他们对于全科医生默认患者的医学影像检查请求如何影响医疗资源以及扭曲患者对放射学检查能力期望的看法。本研究的结果对于理解放射学实践不断演变的动态及其挑战至关重要。
2023年11月至2024年2月期间,对澳大利亚各地私立多专科医疗中心的放射科医生进行了一项全面的横断面意见调查。该调查包括通过同一家公司的内联网平台分发的结构化和开放式问题,涵盖了广泛的放射科医生。向放射科医生发送了100份调查问卷,共收到37份回复,回复率为37%。其中,10份回复不完整,剩余27份用于分析。
近一半的参与者(48%)拥有超过20年的经验。大多数放射科医生自我报告称,X线检查(27%)、超声检查(25%)和计算机断层扫描(CT)(24%)是最常被要求进行的非必要影像检查。放射科医生将这些请求归因于患者接触在线医疗信息以及他们寻求安心的愿望。由于临床病史与为解决临床问题而要求的影像检查或程序之间缺乏相关性,约24%的放射学检查被认为是不必要的,30%的放射科医生报告称感到来自全科医生和患者要求加快报告完成的压力。提出的策略包括患者教育、沟通以及制定明确的指南。
该研究凸显了患者主动发起的影像检查给放射科医生带来的负担可能会不断增加。正如被调查者所认为的,患者不切实际的期望以及对诊断性影像检查局限性的缺乏了解,使这种负担进一步加重。放射科医生强调了更广泛的医疗环境在应对此类请求方面的关键作用。强调了患者教育对于减少不必要的影像检查和管理患者期望的重要性。
对患者进行诊断性影像检查的局限性和合理使用方面的教育,有助于减少不必要的请求并管理患者期望。该研究强调需要有清晰的、基于证据的指南,以协助全科医生应对患者对不必要影像检查的需求。该研究的另一个贡献是,放射科医生、全科医生和患者之间需要改进沟通策略,以确保对影像检查请求采取协作方式,从而减轻放射科医生的工作量压力。最后,本研究凸显了避免不必要的影像检查如何能够缓解资源紧张、优化工作流程并提高患者护理质量。